Obviously this " Feather " scenario and Henry saying that Hades could've lied
Since they signed Sean coming back .hmmm
Your thoughts
Maybe his soul/essence is a prisoner in the underworld. One would think that "Feather" clue should mean something.
~^~ "All Games Contain the Concept of Death" James Douglas Morrison ~^~
I think he is in the Underworld, but will somehow be able to talk to Regina through the mirror.
I wonder if he went straight to wherever good people move on to and he just skipped the Underworld entirely. His death was visually very different from Hades. Robin's soul left his body and went up, he didn't crumple into a pile of dust that went down. And that could be because Robin was shot and not stabbed, or because he's a mortal and Hades was a god, but Robin was a good guy and Hades was a bad guy. I think he's in some blissful afterlife, and we'll only see him in flashbacks this season. Of course it's also possible that whoever's in charge up there might send him back, because it's so unfair that Killian was returned and Robin wasn't.
http://thinkingoutloud-descartes.blogspot.com/
They're using him in flashbacks I think. As to where he actually went...I'm pretty sure he just went immediately to heaven/afterlife for good people since he sacrificed himself to save someone else. Hades was just a dick who wanted to emotionally torture them. Maybe the 'obliterate' effect is only when used on gods, or maybe it's simply the only thing that can actually kill them and nothing more. Which would raise the question of where a god's soul goes if he/she is killed X.x
shareMaybe a god like Hades doesn't have a soul, as such. Maybe as an immortal creature, what you see is what you get. Robin's soul popped out but Hades just went down. I like your idea of the obliterate effect being something that happens with gods.
http://thinkingoutloud-descartes.blogspot.com/
It is strange how Robin died compared to Hades. I didn't realize until it was pointed out. I wonder if Zeus pulled Robin's soul out because it was bluefish white . And when Hook saw Zeus it was a whitish surrounding.
But it wouldn't make sense to have Zeus save Hook and not Robin, unless he couldn't
Or maybe because Hades was a god he crumpled
It just doesn't make sense that Zeus saved Hook. He just did. There is no sense or plot logic to find behind it.
Maybe Zeus couldn't save Robin because Robin went "upstairs" past him. He sent Killian back as a reward for helping to defeat Hades, Robin deserves the same reward, but if Robin went straight to the happy afterlife beyond Zeus, he might be beyond Zeus' power. After all, we keep talking about hell but the gang wasn't in hell, and Hades wasn't the devil. It begs the question, if something is lower than Hades, is there also something higher than Zeus?
http://thinkingoutloud-descartes.blogspot.com/