MovieChat Forums > Great Expectations (2013) Discussion > Another unattractive Estella

Another unattractive Estella


Yet another unattractive Estella (I'm not talking about young Estella) Can't feel the magic when Estella is not pretty, looking more like a young Julianne Moore, who also isn't pretty.

reply

Wow, that's harsh. I found adult Estella to be absolutely beautiful. She isn't the cookie cutter beauty admired in today's society, but she has an air about her and very lovely features and certainly in the period in which the story is set she would have been considered very handsome.

reply

Holliday Grainger is a stereotypical 'english rose' pale, perfect skin, red lips. She may mot be a stick insect with bleached hair extensions like what is stereotypically attractive now but she looks how Dickens probably imagined her.

reply

Really? I thought she was stunning, especially when we first see adult Estella

reply

I think Julianne Moore is gorgeous and I think this Estella is pretty, but she's not that cruel beauty I pictured reading it. Despite the modernization and major changes I still think the Ethan Hawke/Gwyneth Paltrow version best captures the intense drama I felt reading it. I would have probably cast someone more like Imogen Poots, but everyone is entitled to their opinion.

reply

I saw the movie and she is sexy.

reply

Considering you prefer boys, why should we care WHAT you think?

reply

I really thought that she was absolutely beautiful, Holliday has this natural beauty with a glimpse of innocence mixed with mysteriousness, she was totally credible and way prettier than Gwyneth Paltrow, as Estella she was more believable.

---------------------
Sorry, I'm French. For real !

reply

[deleted]

Excuse me? Take that back.
Estella is gorgeous in this film, I couldn't take my eyes off her.

reply

Estella is exactly like she's described in the book. She isn't supposed to be drop dead gorgeous, some people seem to forget that. Pip isn't supposed to be really good looking either as I recall.

"Don't they know they're making love to one already dead?!"

Love Les Miserables!!!

reply