MovieChat Forums > The Exes (2011) Discussion > Ripped off 'The Odd Couple' (the movie a...

Ripped off 'The Odd Couple' (the movie and play)


Some of the lines in the first episode are stolen practically word for word from "The Odd Couple" like when Stuart tells Phil that he wants to thank him for taking him in and giving him a place to live after Phil gets exasperated with him. Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau play this same scene in the movie. And when Stuart is on the couch with the girl talking about his ex, and then they both tear up and start crying. Total rip off of the movie as well, when Jack Lemmon breaks down with the two divorcees' over dinner and Walter Matthau comes in with drinks thinking everyone is having a good time. It's so blatant Neil Simon could sue them for plagarism. That movie and the original play is a classic and it was really cheap of them to rip it off. Especially for the start of a "new" show. I really can't believe that they even had the balls to do it.

reply

Um yeah this is the first time a tv show ever did the same scene as a movie or another tv show!! GMAB!


"OMG you're about to jibber-jabber about jibber-jabber"."

reply

Also, <sarcasm> only two times in history (including real life) that anyone has ever taken in a friend after a divorce or breakup and the person taking them in gets exasperated at some point and the friend breaks down and thanks them profusely for taking them in. Or only two times someone leaves the room thinking all is fine and returns to find the people he left now commiserating in some way.

The second example actually made me think of an example from Frasier that isn't exact (not romantic), but Frasier's father has his poker game to which even female Roz (Frasier's producer) is invited. She recently learned that she's pregnant. Martin leaves the room to get fresh drinks for everyone (there's element one) and tells someone to tell a certain funny story he's mentioned. He also asks Roz if she wants a beer. She says she doesn't and says, "Remember?" This exchange leads to her revealing that she's pregnant, and they all begin to tell stories about their children, which quickly turns to a "it's over so soon" type mood. When Martin returns to the room, still thinking his friend has been regaling them with some funny old story they share, everyone is just sitting there looking glum. (There's element two, albeit not actually crying.) He looks confused and says, "I don't think you told that story right."

It's almost like saying that because two people were left alone or stranded somewhere (well, that's difficult to achieve with technology today) and they end up having a romantic night together it's like [fill in the blank.] I'm not sure which film originated that one nor that The Odd Couple did with the type of scene mentioned here, but it just obviously made a huge impact on the OP.

Or maybe it was a blatant homage. I haven't seen the episode. Either way, those are not unusual human experiences.

The perfect human being is uninteresting. -Joseph Campbell

{Ignore phone posting errors.}

reply

You have to watch the movie "The Odd Couple" to understand my point. The one with Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau. They rip it off verbatim, the exact same dialogue that Lemmon says to Matthau in the movie, the guy Stuart says to the other two guys. That is just pathetic and lazy writing from a bad writing staff. And they think people are so stupid they're not going to notice. But, then again, people who know and watch great movies like "The Odd Couple" written by the brilliant Neil Simon who WAS an original don't watch drivel like The Exes. I watched like two episodes mostly for Donald Faison and I was over it. The characters are like cartoons, it was just stupidity. So the writers are actually smart in thinking that the audience for such a stupid show would never connect it to a great play and movie like "The Odd Couple".

reply