Laugh Track


I could watch this show if it wasn't for the ubiquitous and annoying laugh track playing after almost every sentence. Other good comedies do not resort to this outdated method. This isn't the 50s, nor 60s. Listening to people's uproarious laughter at mildly amusing lines is ridiculous. Is it supposed to cue the tv audience to know when to laugh? Seriously, what is the reason for a laugh track? Let the comedic lines stand on their own. If you have to use a laugh track to "suggest" to the audience that something is funny, you apparently are not very good at writing comedy.

reply

They used to do it before a studio audience. I don't know why they stopped unless they had issues with rowdy audience members.

reply

I can absolutely confirm that it is recorded in front of a live studio audience. I was in the audience for this season's episode, "My Name is Rob." The laughter is genuine. It may be augmented in post-production but it's definitely real. There was a warm-up comic working the audience to keep the energy level up before the show started and during the times when things on set were being reset. He made general suggestions about laughing as boisterously as possible overall but there was never a sign or anything that said, "Laugh now," or anything like that.

As I recall, they showed at least one pre-recorded scene at the appropriate time because one of the actors was not going to be available for the studio taping time (Jay Leno apparently had a stand-up gig that conflicted with the taping). I suspect they do the same thing (although I have no direct knowledge of this) for scenes that are outdoors (e.g. Mutton Busting) or may be otherwise too technically difficult to film on set. While I'm sure this is done for the sake of adding the audience's laughter to the audio track, it's also to the studio audience's benefit to be able to watch the scene at the right point to get the flow of the entire episode.

reply

Yeah, I remember seeing at least part of the audience when Tim directed an episode earlier this year.

Still don't know why they stopped saying it is filmed in front of a live studio audience. Not that it matters; I still love the show.

reply

It's why I originally never even watched the show until a little over a year ago. Laugh tracks are awful (and for the record, I still count studio audiences as a laugh track..it's more the general sense of audible laughter than the technical aspect of how it's presented). Then I heard about the themes of the some of the episodes and it made me curious so I checked it out. I still haven't watched all of it (or any of season 1) but I've seen probably 60-70% by now.

Thing is if it's an older show like HI or ELR..I can handle it fine. Maybe I'm just getting snobbier with shows and feel we should be past the laugh track I don't know. But I do also feel it's outdated.


A funny example of how corny it is was in an episode of It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia where they were referencing the shows that often get nominated/victories for Emmys (Season 9 Episode 3 for reference) by using another bar that tells people when to drink.

Episode Preview
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qT2SfODvfFQ


Good jokes will help ease the pain of a laugh track but I still prefer the style of It's Always Sunny, The Office, Curb Your Enthusiasm ect.

reply

I agree. The laugh track is unbearable. It was at one time before a studio audience. Personally, I prefer comedies with no laughing at all. I know when to laugh. I don't need any prodding.

reply

My wife and I were discussing this just last night. I mentioned to her that until lately, the very first voice you heard after the opening credits said, "LMS is filmed before a live studio audience". That served to me as proof that they were indeed using a laugh track, and it made me just a little bit sad and disappointed in the 65+ Exec. Prod's. that they don't believe in the show enough to just eliminate the laugh track altogether. They would rather depend on a laugh track to announce something was funny rather than trust that their audience is intelligent enough to get the funny parts when applicable and zero trust in their writers to deliver a scene that is funny without the need for the laugh track.

Damnit Meredith... your BOOB is out!

reply

I do have to wonder because earlier in the season Tim directed an episode, and they had at least a partial audience.

reply

They have always filmed in front of a live audience--that has remained the same way from Day 1 (apparently that's a Tim Allen requirement). They just don't announce it anymore (that didn't start until Season 3 anyway, right?). Now, how much altering they do between filming and airing, I have no idea.

reply

I wonder if there is something in the guidelines which says to claim "Filmed in front..." there has to be so much of it "filmed in front" or something like that. 

I don't really care - I enjoy the show regardless.

reply

I think, but don't know for certain, that the "Filmed in front of a live studio audience" thing was started to differentiate shows from ones with canned laughter since canned laughter has such a bad reputation.

How I Met Your Mother was filmed and then shown to an audience in order to get their laugh track. They said there were so many flash backs, flash forwards, and sideways and set changes that it would've been torture to put a studio audience through that.

reply

It may be filmed before a live audience but what we hear on the tv is definitely augmented with laugh track. The laugh level and sound is the same one every time. With a live audience there is a lot of variation in laughter. And audiences don't laugh so strongly at mildly amusing lines. There is a definite difference that is easily heard between a real audience laugh and a ubiquitous laugh track.

reply

Are all you people morons? THERE IS NO LAUGH TRACK.

reply

You most likely won't read it but I'll reply anyway:
It actually IS a laugh track!
Yes, it is recorded in front of a live studio audience but the laughter is recorded separately into its OWN audio track. They have microphones above the audiences heads and those are recorded by themselves (maybe even separate from each other so there would be several tacks).
You can NOT hear the audience through the microphones (mostly so-called boom-mics) that record the actors since they're made to JUST record the actors. Mostly the mics are above the actors (and you can sometimes even see them - watch Two guys, a girl and a pizza place - you can see the mics ALL the time!).
After the taping those several recordings are put each into a track of an audio mixer (in the computer nowadays) so they are separate tracks with the actors and separate tracks with the audience's laughter - ergo laugh tracks.
Most people though think laugh tracks are pre-recorded laughs added later which was only true for parts of "How I met your mother" and "Anger management" which were not shot in front of an audience. They were taped and THEN shown to an invited audience after they were edited.
"How I met your mother" however had often scenes never shown to the invited audience due to the secrecy of those scenes and used canned laughter for the.
I have been to tapings of several shows and behind-the-scenes of "Big Bang Theory", "Two broke girls" and "Two and a half men" (but with Ashton Kutcher). I was able to see and talk to cast and crew on all three shows.
Oh - and by the way: The main reason why the laughter is so often and loud... You have to imagine that the people who go to the shows are BIIIIG FANS of these shows. They love the shows so the laugh more. No need to tell them when to laugh. But yes, there's always a comedian to keep the people entertained while the wait for set and actor changes - so called moving-on. The audience gets water and food - mostly pizza or sandwiches - and candy. It's fun!

reply

Look at all the pretentious arty-farty folks who like to act like comedies without a "laught track" are superior just to feel smart about themselves. It creates the atmosphere of a theatre, it's not intended to tell you when something is funny. A studio audience is great, it makes clear to the actors and writers when a joke is NOT funny.

reply