Too many Flaws to be taken Seriously..(Major Spoilers!!)

1. Why did Bhaskaran send Khan into kolkata to investigate about Milan if he himself was the Kingpin. Wouldn't he be scared that khan being non-complicit and an honest officer might get to know about the whole plot?? If I was Bhaskaran I would try to sweep this whole thing under the carpet.

Why shouldn't he? If he sends he'd know in advance for what is happening at Kolkotta and take appropriate action. Bhaskaran thought that Khan didn't suspect him and was the one who'd honestly update him.

2. When Khan was hatching this elaborate plot to use Vidya to cath Milan didn't he keep Bhaskaran in loop?? He clearly reports to his boss after he interrogates vidya for the first time..So clearly he should tell Bhaskaran about his plan to catch Milan and take consent,or atleast discuss it.

Not exactly this way, but one can surely point as a hole by saying that since Khan used to update Bhaskaran, he would have also told Bhaskaran that they're investigating on a potential suspect working at NDC (i.e. Shridhar), the night Rana and Vidya intruded Sridhar's office followed by Sridhar getting killed. Bhaskaran could have immediately alerted Sridhar about it. For this may be we can guess that Khan decided to act on his own and for that he enrolled Rana and stopped updating Bhaskaran.

Would like to hear some comments from other users on this.

3. Why would Bhaskaran choose Milan to confront Vidya?? He was the guy he was hiding at all cost.Couldn't he have sent someone else to get those files? or for that matter couldn't he just bump her off way earlier much like he did to Agnes and The doctor?? Don't tell me he was sympathetic towards the pregnant woman. His whole career and life is on the line here.

This has been answered by shantanab-lone-voyager on other thread: "After Bob Biswas (contract killer) was killed, maybe there were no other contract killer available at that particular moment, so despite the fact that IB chief, by now, was aware that Vidya had important info - he had to send Milan to kill her...
it may also be that he never suspected Vidya to be an assassin who wants to kill Milan (for personal revenge), he rather feared that those info will get into the hands of other IB officers and wanted to retrieve the info badly."

I have a slightly different take to explain it going by aesthetic of story . I take this as Film-Noir element. The movie only revolves around the set of characters and they seem larger than life but are much life like in their action. In Film-Noirs it won't happen that the bad guys has army of people who'd send their men to bump off someone. The Maltese Falcon. One assassin, one middle man, one femme-fatale and one protagonist, a detective who knows nothing but just acts towards potential leads.

These are characters which attribute to Film-Noir. Kind of characters who are overconfident, medium-intelligent, cynical but Life-like, and short-term opportunists. Milan may be just a common man - who might have acted as per instructions of Bhaskaran or somehow gets in touch with Bhaskaran who intun is a part of a conspiracy to sell/transport the chemical weapons. We don't know Milan's exact role. But after the incident, he hid himself. And Bhaskaran too must be acting on instructions of some international group (just speculations) and they were left on their own to tackle things after the mishap.

The Possibility for me is:-

After the train Mishap, Milan who is a common guy and not someone who could fly-off to Mauritius, fled and hid himself in India. Bhaskaran wouldn't take any chance if Milan gets caught at the Airport. Bhaskaran, by his personal interest would also want Milan to get killed (who knows?) but can't let Milan get captured alive otherwise Milan would expose him. The best he could do was to mislead the investigation which takes the IB to Milan and keep him hiding. At the end, after Shridhar and Bob were dead, he had no option other than to send Milan himself to meet Vidya and kill her (because she called Bhaskaran that she knows that Sridhar's PC had his mobile number).

We can see that Milan was living in some slum, so he might be not be so rich. He must have got carried away to do a task for which Sridhar and Bhaskaran also were involved as one time project (to transport/sell the technology/chemical), but things went wrong. They weren't by themselves such big people who have hired men working for them.

5. After hacking Shridhar’s computer and copying all the files, the only file that seemed odd was the file that Bhaskaran’s number stored (ha ha) cryptically. This file had Bhaskaran’s number in an alphabet code. what’s wrong with Shridhar having Bhaskaran’s number. After all, the IB seemed to have been sending their officers to NDC quite frequently and it’s normal for Shridhar to have known Bhaskaran. So, how did Nawaz conclude only the basis of that stupid cryptic code that his boss is the brains behind it all? FAR-Fetched!!

Because it was stored in a cryptic code. Had it been just simply a number, he wouldn't have suspected it. And Sridhar must have stored the number in that coded form, much before IB's first investigation on NDC.

For certain aspects of the movie, we will find it silly or mediocre because of its lack of presentation and uniqueness. This is because we've seen so many Hollywood movies who are far better in their presentation. If this was Hollywood movie, it wouldn't have the 'mobile number stored in coded form' thing - may be - but something else much presentable which would look intelligent and beyond people's reach of technology.

We should appreciate this movie's efforts, that's what I am saying and not compare directly to some smart HW flick. For me, this movie is nothing less (and ocassionally better) than The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo where that girl keeps hacking computers and stealing informations from Libraries and stealing Billions of dollars from different world accounts. One can surely find some holes there too, if he/she wants to.

6.the killing of agnes made no sense, She would have gotten the old file of Milan, Big Deal!! Didn't vidya find it later anyway and nothing conclusive came out of it. neither did the killing of Sridhar by Vidya made any sort of sense. If at all that guy would have helped to nab Sridhar!! Why kill him Vidya??

They didn't know that Ms Agnes ALREADY Puked the information about Tyaagi and the Back-up office (where they stored hard copies). It was too late for them.


Next we have Peter Breene...

reply share

add reply

formatting help