AWESOME!!!
I'm a big fan from the book since I've read it long time ago. I love to see a new screenplay for it made with such effort as this one. I don't mind minor changes, I do not think a movie should replace a novel and do exatcly the same, I want a new flavor, a more contemporary look at classic stories.
That being said I like everything on this adaptation. The pirates are real bad-ass and it took one and a half hour to even get to the island! That's what I call character and tension building!
No silly love affairs, no teenage *beep* no Bad vs Evil maniqueism.... this is the best Pirate movie i've seen on a long, long time (yes, I'm talking to you Pirates of the Caribbean)