Fooled by man-bun mentalist? Really?

Showed aired today, Nov. 25, 2016. Man-bun mentalist (didn't catch his name) did the "hey look I've pulled Carlos -- a random person out of the audience -- complete stranger -- and darned if I don't have a card embossed with his name and birthdate on it" trick.

And the great Penn & Teller weren't fooled because they thought he had a printer hidden under a cloth-covered table?

They ever hear of a plant? Carlos obviously was not a "random person."