Thor is evil now???


Why on earth would a king want to defeat Thor? The same Thor who according to asatru and norse mythology went out of his way to protect mankind.

"Only one man can stop him... Eirick, the undead." The only undead kings to roam the land were the unholy, unheroic shameful cowards and betrayors from the kingdom of Hel. They fought with the destructive giants, whos sole purpose was to ruin the world of mankind The battleslain heroes were brought to Valhalla in Asgard. Odin gathered them to fight the destructive forces of giants.

The storyline seems to be christian propaganda, promoted by Christian missionaries who once prosecuted, tortured and in many cases beheaded followers of the old ways.

This movie is an insult, both to believers in Asatru, and to the memory those stood up against the ruthless christian missionaries.

Anybody agree/disagree?

reply

Frankly, any semblance this so-called movie might have to an ages old mythic cultural phenomenon must surely be purely coincidental. As you say, the movie is a perversion of Scandinavian lore as much as it is audience robbery. Historical or even mythic accuracy is never a strong point or even considered here, but the saving grace is, neither were other so-called adaptations of myths which cost considerably more; Wrath of the Titans, Clash of the Titans, Troy and The Immortals all defecated upon the original source material, and some accepted these films on their own merits, which were admittedly few, but the gall to perform a revisioning which occasionally looked well done saved it in my view

Vi Veri Veniversum Vivus Vici
By the power of truth I, while living, have conquered the universe

reply

Hold on. Troy was appalling in terms of its source material, but Clash of the Titans rocked. (The old one, I haven't seen the new one.) A lot of those movies were great and sometimes not far from the sources.

reply

While I agree, its a perversion of norse mythology, I dont think people realize, that christanity, advocates for the destruction of the world (armageddon everyone?) So why this movie tried to make out THOR wanted the end of the world only. Is plain ridiculous.

As an atheist though, I think, all the mythical gods are just figments of human imaginations, however since there are many Christians around today, and not many Asatru believers, then it makes sense they wouldn't overtly attack or alienate potential audience members.

All the same *beep* though, I just enjoyed it for what it was, a simple action movie, somewhat entertaining, as I havent seen a viking based film in along while.

reply

Im just in it for the action, i won't even get into the story, won't affect me, or anyone else, and if someone is getting insulted by this, it's their problem, stop whining, the only way to kill religions is to kill the whole lot of their followers.

The increase in human knowledge is the cause of the decline of religions.

reply

Why does it have to be propaganda? Does it have a message it tries to comunicate? What if instead of trying to influence the audience, is a somewhat accurate depiction of what christianity tried to do in the past: purge from every culture their gods.

By tradition non-christian gods were depicted in the image of man, so it would also be natural to Thor to get enraged, after his cult was being dropped for christianity.

"Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people."

reply

Disagree. The story is about gods feeling betrayed and (even more so) being pissed of about it. The fact Thor fights against Christianity is because it is the biggest (new) religion in that timeperiod.

It is in fact the old ways fighting against change.

A god (either Thor or God or any) that has feelings of hatred and envy has to be a false god.

reply

I agree. It states clearly at the end that now mankind has the right to choose who they wish to worship ... that concept of Western thought is rare in the world apart from the Judeo Christian culture. Japan has it now too since their defeat in World War II, but look what's happening to Christians in any country that doesn't have a Christian majority ... the threat of death is a serious one.

The Scandinavian people chose Christianity on their own after centuries of burning, pillaging and r**ing others throughout Europe. It didn't happen overnight, but they became peaceful. And that was something the Norse religion didn't offer.

reply

Christianity has its own history of "burning, pillaging and r**ing others throughout Europe" and the rest of the world. You might know some of them as the Crusades, inquisitions, with hunts, and forced conversions. Christanity was forced upon many people throughout Europe by their rulers. I wonder how much of the "right to choose" you can really attribute to Christianity itself and not to other schools of thought or at least changes in Christianity.

reply

The Scandinavian people chose Christianity on their own


Wow! you're suffering from a big bout of christinsanity for believing that. The Samis weren't converted till around the 18th century.


---
Scientologists love Narnia, there's plenty of closet space.

reply

... And they chose it on their own

reply

Godt spørsmål ;-)

reply