MovieChat Forums > Fatmagül'ün Suçu Ne? (2021) Discussion > very low imdb score !! so misleading

very low imdb score !! so misleading

posted 8 years ago by amaryllis93
2 replies | jump to latest

i am just wondering why is this series is rated 5, it's maybe the best turquish drama i have ever seen it's full of emotions and the acting is so well done , the story is also very beautifull and touching , i know that it's about something considered as a taboo in those conservatives countries and a lot of people had a problem with the rape scene which they consider too explicit but that's not a reason to judge the whole story as bad
anyway i just think it's unfaire to the series who wached this and agree ? (sorry for my bad english)

[–] ramansohanpal 8 years ago

This show is now being aired in india. I started watching it because of storyline but slowly it hooked me so badly that i watch its videos in turkish too. Its very beautiful show espcially engin. His expressions and style is soo good .kerim and fatma love story is most beautiful.to those who find it awful .i would say kerim was totally blanked out on that day and till the end he felt guilty.that guilt was there even on their wedding night.engin as kerim is so believable that we fall in love with him amd forgive him.Forgiveness does matter.

[–] PaulVilla 7 years ago

I just submitted a review where I explain my reason. I don't think it matches everyone's reason. But it should give you some idea why the rating is so low.

The show begins very strong. It is a big world with lots of characters & suspense. But in the later half of the show, the primary focus (or obsession) becomes Fatmagul & Kerim's relationship.

This becomes a no-win situation for the show.

If they present it directly as a romance, some part of the audience would correctly be upset that Kerim - who chased her constantly & put the rapists attention on her - would be accepted as her lover...over someone like Mustafa who knew & loved her from childhood.

So they present it as an indirect romance, and this upsets another part of the audience. They have to watch Kerim constantly apologizing & demanding Fatmagul's love. This just repeats & repeats until Fatmagul gives in. This is not very romantic or satisfying to watch.

In my review, I explain why the reconciliation of Fatmagul & Mustafa was a more realistic & romantic story to have pursued. They would have utilized the same elements of Kerim & Fatmagul's relationship...but it would be more realistic & poignant.

Plus, it would bring all separate threads of the series together...because of Mustafa's direct involvement with both Fatmagul & the Yessaran's. Under Kerim & Fatmagul, the stories became too separate & the actual rape case lost focus.