MovieChat Forums > Upstairs Downstairs (2011) Discussion > What is Mr Amanjit's status now?

What is Mr Amanjit's status now?


He's not really a guest... He's not really a servant... What does he live on..? Did Lady Maud leave him some money..? Generally, I enjoy the show. So, I don't like to accuse it of box-ticking. But, if you were being cynical, you could say Mr Amanjit is only there so we can have a non-white character... Miss Pamela was more central to the three-parter, but has also become a bit of a "box-ticking" character... The deliciously louche Duke of Kent and, possibly, Mr Pritchard represent the gay community, but are properly embedded in the show... It's not a huge problem. But, I think it would be fairly easily solved by making Mr Amanjit's status clearer and by involving Miss Pamela a bit more, rather than just having her pop up from time to time.

reply

He's definitely a servant, albeit one with an administrative role i.e. sorting through his late employer's papers/dealing with the Kindertransport charity etc. I guess that socially, he'd be on a par with a governess or a companion.

I agree about Miss Pamela. I don't know how much scope this particular actress has, having not seen her in anything before, but I hope that she's not just there to "be Down Syndromy" and not say anything more than "hello Agnes" or "thank you Pritchard". That would make me uncomfortable. I dislike tokenism. I hope she gets a story.

reply

I was wondering who the woman and the girl were that he was meeting in a restaurant? Is the girl his daughter?

I will always be on the side of those who have nothing - F G Lorca

reply

[deleted]

XP with upstairs...93

reply

[deleted]

Sorry - it means "cross posted" ! I was just too lazy to type it in full *laughing*

reply

[deleted]

Thanks! I had totally forgotten about Rachel the maid from the first series. I wish they'd repeated the first series before showing this one, it would have refreshed my memory!

I will always be on the side of those who have nothing - F G Lorca

reply

[deleted]

I'd forgotten that Art Malik was in Jewel in the Crown! Yes, I remember the scene in question; it was distressing to watch and must have been uncomfortable to act.

I hope they do introduce a romance for Mr Amanjit - crossing the racial boundaries should certainly cause some fall out!

I will always be on the side of those who have nothing - F G Lorca

reply

Janey: Mr. Amanjit is considered "white" so there should not be a skin color problem (other than a FEW unsophisticated people).

Some folks are concerned about his religion (Sikh) but that has nothing to do with his skin color. In fact, the color of his skin has nothing to do with his classification as "white." Even if some are darker than blacks, they are till considered white!

reply

[deleted]

He had a contract with the BBC and they couldn't get out of it.

reply

*laughing at torrgran's comment*

Janey, the girl is Lotte, the daughter of the German Jewish servant, Rachel, who appeared in the first series. The family and Mr Amanjit were keen for Lotte to be cared for and educated after Rachel's death, and I imagine that Mr A. did all the necessary sorting out. The lady is the headmistress/form teacher(?) at Lotte's boarding school. She took in more Jewish girls via the Kindertransport so is presumably in touch with Mr Amanjit for these two reasons.

reply

Keep in mind that Hallam is a high-level civil servant in pre-WWII London; a mandarin who knows where many of the bodies are buried. As such, he has to be “careful” of who is in his home, and has access to his information. Mr. Amanjit is silent as a tomb, and had been vetted by Hallam’s mother, which is a huge assurance. Remember when he told Hallam that he would have to “threaten him” before he would go through Maud’s private papers?

Hallam has to work long hours and he has a wife with a baby (then small children) at home and a household that is larger than the average civil servant. Therefore, Hallam needs reliable help, and loyal support, and he has the money to cover expenses for that help and support. In this instance, his wife is just about worthless (as his mother reminded him when the government was in crisis and he needed help in “talking and unwinding to someone who would keep his confidences” yet Agnes was “out shopping for prams”). And, when Agnes did come home from shopping, or the beauty shop, or tea with her friends (or her idiot sister) she didn’t want to hear about his work. She wanted “time for them to enjoy each other” and didn’t seem to understand that she had an obligation to “help” her husband, and that “listening to his concerns” is part of her “job” for the pleasures of shopping and going to the beauty shop and having her time as her own. She refuses to “invest” 45 minutes listening to her husband unwind over cocktails after work, yet she can “shop” and gossip for six hours at a time; she gives women a bad name.

As a result of his elite upbringing, and his current job responsibilities, and his wife’s attitude, Hallam needs help, and the chance at keeping Amanjit by his side is a gift. Remember when he was concerned about outside trouble, and he was as Whitehall long hours, he gave the gun to Amanjit and told him to use it at his discretion; to keep Agnes and the children safe, come what may. While there were other males in the household (Mr. Pritchard, the chauffeur, Johnny), the male that Hallam would trust with the gun was Amanjit.

Mr. Amanjit is currently functioning as a “major domo” to the household and as an aide-de-camp to Hallam. Amanjit has the respect of those both above and below stairs; he can handle matters too delicate for Mr. Pritchard, and he can handle situations too tough for the chauffeur or Johnny. He works well with Hallam’s aunt, in her war work. And, he functions well with Agnes, probably because he is clear as to his position and would never “cross her” unless it was for the betterment of the household. All in all, he more than pays for his keep.

reply