Opening shot


What's the significance of the opening shot with Hannelore Knuts? Is it supposed to refer to the Gustave Courbet painting? Or is it just to get the viewers interested?

reply

It's just ridiculous and has nothing to do with the rest of the movie. Speculative garbage.
The rest of the film had it's qualities though.

reply

Thanks. I'd still be curious what the director was intending there.

reply

Me too. I've been searching for interviews about certain things in this movies but all he seems to talk about is the visual aspect. I've concluded that he just tries to provoke.

reply

If you understand Dutch, there are some answers here: http://www.filmkrant.nl/TS_mei_2012/7935

reply

I can read some, but not very good. Translate the main point for me?

reply

Provost says that, as a man, his life's meaning is driven by "the mystery of the woman". He wants the opening "Courbet shot" to suggest that the film's story comes out of the woman's vagina (remember Courbet's painting is called "The Origin of the World") and it also forms the protagonist's unattainable goal throughout the film/his life.

Provost also says that the entire opening shot can be seen as some sort of commercial ad for Europe: a depiction of a carefree and prosperous world where modern, liberated women play the main role.

If that all sounds far-fetched, it's very standard Freudian/Lacanian stuff. It's quite cliché but Freud's famous quote is of course that the one question he couldn't answer in his life was: "Was will das Weib?" And Lacan actually used to own that very Courbet painting and kept it privately and covered up. So Provost seems to share that obsession.

I like it how the opening shot forms some sort of mythological "genesis" of the film's narrative; it's the set-up that, via the tunnel sequence that follows it (which is also part of the narrative: the protagonist travels from the Spanish shore to the city of Brussels), brings us to the "actual" beginning of the film, where the protagonist has ended up as an illegal construction worker. That's the point where the film starts "rolling"; what happened before fades away like a sort of dream.

reply

Thank you, ChefGaspard.

I am proud of myself for getting the reference to Gustave Courbet!

There was also a film by Wayne Wang, The Center of the World, that used this painting as inspiration: imdb.com/title/tt0240402/

reply

Lots of BS above here...

It just means that some ly naked on the beach all day long, and some strugle for
life...

reply