MovieChat Forums > Apollo 18 (2011) Discussion > Did everyone miss this?

Did everyone miss this?


Or am I an idiot? In the movie, the moon rocks are shown to be a spider like creature of some kind. However, there is no air pressure on the moon and the temperature is either -230~-240 Fahrenheit. So, exactly how is it possible that these alien creatures survived in these conditions? It seems they have been there several years, and they walk quickly, in the sun, with no apparent ill effects. Did I miss something? Or did the filmmakers include that knowing it was so stupid no one would notice it? Who knows, maybe I missed something.

reply

Um because they're aliens I guess? This movie was a letdown!

reply

Your question is not a stupid one. With this you have to think outside the box. Not every living organism needs oxygen to live. We as humans need oxygen to survive. It is possible that another species doesn't need oxygen to live and that they can survive even the harshest conditions like -240 F or even at +240 F. You just gotta think bigger and not just look in a straight line. Everything is not what it seems.

reply

The Moon is completely airless, so there would be no pressure to hold the aliens together.

reply

You don't need air to hold things together so long as their structural integrity can withstand the pressure differential. And that's assume there IS a difference in pressure between the inside or the outside. Who knows what life evolved to survive in a vacuum would be like?

reply

Not a product of natural evolution, but one speculative fiction guy came up with a possible human descendant capable of living in an airless void:

http://www.sivatherium.narod.ru/library/Dixon_3/04_en.htm

reply

There's no pressure to hold the rocks together but unsurprisingly they don't explode or sublimate...

reply

There are organisms that live at the bottom of the ocean, where the pressure is many times greater than the surface. The moon vs the surface of Earth is only 1 ATM of pressure different.

reply

Try The Andromeda Strain the original not the remake,there the alien organism was I believe sillicon based and chrystaline in structue and it growed when exposed to x-rays.

reply

Not every single creature is the same as you and I. We, humans, cannot survive the depths of the ocean while other creatures are perfectly fine. Wouldn't it be logical to assume that a creature can thus also survive in an environment other than earth.

Is that too simple?

reply

[deleted]

Clearly the ability for life on the moon to able to sabotage a manned space mission (in the hope of riding the spacecraft back to Earth) must conver an evolutionary advantage!

Apparently it worked because the Apollo astronauts did bring plenty of moon rocks back with them... I wonder if any of them went missing under mysterious circumstances!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-16909592

reply

theperfectmarysuekiller wrote:
However, there is no air pressure on the moon and the temperature is either -230~-240 Fahrenheit.

The surface temperature on the Moon fluctuates between -240F at night and +250F in the day. There's a big range for the creatures to find workable play time somewhere in there.

So, exactly how is it possible that these alien creatures survived in these conditions?

Life finds a way. Mutations allow some creatures to survive situations and conditions that others cannot. Look at the wild range of conditions that lifeforms have evolved to handle and even thrive in on Earth: extreme heat, extreme cold, extreme light, absolute darkness, otherwise noxious gases, extreme water pressure, etc. It's mindboggingly bizarre. And yet it's very, very real.

Consider how whales gulp oxygen up on the surface and then dive to extreme low depths for an hour or more: traveling, hunting, mating, fighting, etc. They collect whatever breathing gas that they need (in this case air) inside their bodies, and then take it along for the ride with them as they go about their business. They don't have to breathe continuously.

Perhaps these moon creatures digest inanimate moon rocks and obtain whatever gaseous nutrients that they need, store it up within their bodies, and then they are free to travel upwards beyond the confines of the masses of lunar rock.

If so, it's dubious whether they would be able to survive the entire spaceflight back to Earth, without more moonrock for digestion/respiration.

"Moon rock. I need more moon rock. You gotta give me more moon rock, baby!"

reply