MovieChat Forums > Arbitrage (2012) Discussion > Really enjoyed it, but what about the vi...

Really enjoyed it, but what about the victims family?


Just read the script too and noticed that the girl who died, her family, wasn't involved at all other than the funeral. I know it's Gere's story, but they never touched on what her family was probably thinking which is outrage as to how she ended up in a burned wreck in the middle of the night by herself in an expensive car that wasn't hers. This point could've added some weight to Gere's dilemma. Movie kept my attention though throughout which most films don't do nowadays.

reply

Seems like there definitely could have been more to the story, maybe some extra footage was shot that they deleted? It didn't really make sense how the mother was only in it for a small part. 7/10 I like the movie, however

From dream to dream....we have always been, like an ever flowing stream....

reply

First, it was Julie's car, wasn't. I thought it was she drank too much to drive so Robert drove. He wasn't loaded, but he was many hours without sleep and under tremendous pressure. He really wasn't in shape to drive either.

Second, why do you think Julie's mother should've been in more of the story than she was? She was really a throwaway character. Her scene could've ended up on the cutting room floor and the movie wouldn't have been the worse for it.

I got that the mother was grief-stricken. I'm sure the whole family was outraged that the driver of the car got away and their loved one died...so young and with so much promise. But why would she be angry at Robert? She didn't know Robert was the runaway driver. She didn't know he was her daughter's married lover. All she knew is Robert was the blessed angel who recognized Julie's talent and gave her a huge boost. He was her benefactor. Why would she direct any of her anger at Robert?

I can't understand what you think would have made the movie better with more scenes with Julie's mother? She was a totally peripheral character. The film is an action-suspense drama. Following some side arc with Julie's grieving family showing their outrage over Julie's death would've only slowed the film down badly and been an irrelevant snooze-Fest.

You're right...the movie is Robert's story. Julie's death was an unfortunate footnote in Robert's life, just as Julie herself was.

reply

you replied to my post but it seems like you meant for the OP. are you asking me about the mother?


From dream to dream....we have always been, like an ever flowing stream....

reply