MovieChat Forums > Persecuted (2014) Discussion > How do fundamentalist christians not see...

How do fundamentalist christians not see the irony in this?


If we are talking about persecution then we have to bring up the fact that currently there are thousands of fundamentalist christians working in Africa to slaughter all homosexuals, I'd call that real persecution. Or what about the fact that Nazi soldiers wore emblems that said "God is on our side" or what about the fact that much of today's antisemitism is because christians knew that people hated interest so they forced the jews to be bankers and charge interest so that the masses would hate them. Or what about the fact that Hobby Lobby can now deny their employees health care because apparently an inanimate object can have a belief in a specific religion and can force that belief upon other people. The persecution has and always will come from the evangelical right so don't fall for the bull* about Jesus saving, they want nothing more than to see everyone who disagrees with their beliefs to burn in hell. They are the persecutors, not the persecuted.

reply

AMEN! Let's not forget about people like scott lively who is spreading hatred and fear throughout the world. I read a review on his book "The Pink Swastika" where he claims homosexuals were responsible for the Holocaust. According to the reviewer, who checked all 12 of his references, 8 were outright lies, 2 were half truths, and 2 books that he scott claimed to use as a reference were never even written, thus making those last 2 references also outright lies. His book is what ALL of his anti-Gay propaganda is based, so it is 96% false. I hope there is a special place in hell for scott lively, and those like him.

reply

Muslims kill Christians and homosexuals! And Hobby Lobby is not denying healthcare (you idiot), they are not BEING FORCED to pay for abortions! They still have to cover birth control and other women's health care. CHRISTIANS ARE NOT KILLING ANYBODY!

reply

No one was being forced to pay abortions it was about two specific forms of birth control; IUD's and Plan B, neither of which are abortions. The entire Hobbly Lobby case was based on incorrect information about what those 2 things are. An IUD stops fertilzation and Plan B releases something in the uterus that stops the sperm from swimming. Chief Justice Roberts said that doesn't matter because they are talking about a 'sincerely held' religious belief, meanwhile they do business with china. A country that has had over 300 mil GOV'T FORCED ABORTIONS over the past 30-40 years (1 child policy).

So the outrage by a christian who has no adopted children is that other people shouldn't have birth control so if I can stop it I will. That's what the case was pure and simple.

Consider this: Employer based healthcare premiums are payed by taking money out of your pacheck... they use our money, not the companies. Money that was already in your paycheck and this ruling basically sets the precedent that it doesn't make the money yours once they tax you for healtcare which begs the ultimate question...

...WHY THE *beep* DON'T WE JUST HAVE SINGLE PAYER HEALTHCARE ANYWAY?! THEN THIS WOULDN'T EVEN BE AN ISSUE.

tinyurl.com/7uz28q7
tinyurl.com/aon3jg8
tinyurl.com/yyalynm

reply

I like the cut of your jib

reply

(1) Show an item of that poster that is a lie.

(2) Check your info on the Hobby Lobby decision again. Your facts are off.

(3) The poster specifically referenced the evangelical far right, not all Christians. There is a very significant difference.

(4) There is no danger of Sharia law in the United States but there is demonstrable danger in the far right imposing their particular brand of Christianity on the way other citizens here live.

(5) If you genuinely believe in God and his message of love, you should try behaving in a more civil and compassionate manner. Your mean spirited responses and self righteous taunts of salvation over other people with different beliefs is not representative of his message, his love (for all of us) or his plan for the ways he asks us to get along.

Best wishes.

reply

I am a Christian and God did not tell me to act a rational way. Your idea of how I should act is rubbish. You're in for a huge surprise when all the wars really start and the Christians have left the earth. Make no mistake: GOD IS REAL. He will judge you and decide your destiny. What you should be doing is reading the Bible, listening to the scriptures on audio, praying, repenting, and watching for the signs of the end. Right now you have no clue. You're like a blind man looking who does not care to see. The harbinger is calling. This may be your only warning. Israel, Iran, Muslims, strange weather patterns, mass killings, dead animals washing up out of the waters, zombies, blood moons, earthquakes, etc have all increased. Check them out! Listen to Paul Begley on YouTube. Listen to other Bible scholars. I'm not kidding. WE ARE LIVING IN THE LAST DAYS!!!!!!!

reply

You buy the snake oil in bulk don't you.

reply

I believe it's cheaper than the bath salts you take. Plus snake oil is essentially harmless while bath salts make you wholeheartedly believe things about people that you don't know. This is a movie like Birdman or Hot Tub Time Machine 2, not like Selma. The posts show we on the left need to pull back and see just a slightly bigger than myopic view that it's entertainment, maybe not our type but that's why there are 16 different movies to choose from each week. Let's put away the fangs and claws until something real comes along. I don't think this is a coming truth in America but I did just see 20 innocent men beheaded from Egypt for being Christians so while I agree it's not our type of entertainment, around the world is not going well for Christians and they are alot more tolerated and further down the list than all of us on the left of center over to whomever they say our boogey man is today, idk maybe Elizabeth Warren? But this is harmless. Pick your battles more wisely.

reply

Zombies have increased?

reply

I actually thought you were serious till I read your reply. Now I can see you are just trying to be funny and make Christians look stupid. Zombies?????

reply

"GOD IS REAL"

Yes, and so is Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy. Oh, and so is Harry Potter, definitely real!

reply

You believe in zombies on top of everything else you spouted off, eh? 😱

reply

You are a total *beep* wackjob.

reply

*Sigh*... Ok, I'm not taking sides in this debate, and I knew I shouldn't have clicked on this thread to begin with but I have to address something because this always bugs the hell out of me.


con·tra·cep·tive
[kon-truh-sep-tiv] Show IPA

adjective
1. tending or serving to prevent conception or impregnation.
2. pertaining to contraception.


The phrase contraception by definition means to prevent conception.

The decision in the Hobby Lobby case ruled directly on four forms of birth control(note that I use the phrase birth control, not contraceptive). All four of these operate as a primary method of working post-conception(but typically prior to impregnation in the uterus, yes they are not one and the same). It is in fact their marketing niche("Plan B" in particular, it's the name itself even).

Whether or not post conception but pre impregnation counts as a abortive, I'm not getting into. But the simple fact remains... these 4 methods of birth control *ARE BY DEFINITION NOT CONTRACEPTIVES*. (At least primarily, but I believe at least one or two have a contraceptive secondary function.)

reply

Well said. My objection was to the claim that this had anything to do with abortion, which it does not. And it's inflammatory and misleading when people lodge that claim. Your description was one of the more reasoned to be found in these parts. I'll leave my feelings about the Hobby Lobby decision out of this conversation as that's an entirely different topic but I appreciate your clarification on that particular point.

reply

The whole contraception issue is ridiculous.

When a pregnant woman gets murdered, the killer is tried for DOUBLE HOMICIDE.

This law needs to change. The only way that it is double homicide is if the fetus is treated as a person.

Clearly it is not. This law needs to change. Single homicide for the murder of a pregnant woman. Anything else is just floating the 'fantasy' that the thing in the belly is human.

What country do we live in?

reply

Conception = impregnation. We're not talking the egg embedding in the uterine wall here; the meaning is clear: simple fertilisation.

Also, IUDs, etc are contraceptives; they prevent the egg from becoming fertilised.

The Adventures of The Man With No Penis: http://tinyurl.com/8ezrkh

reply

Atheistic communist regimes have killed millions of believers because of their beliefs. I suggest you educate yourself, unless your dogma trumps truth. Then just ignore facts.

reply

Fundies live in a world that bears NO resemblance to reality.

Scott Lively IS advocating murder against gays in Africa. He & the other American Taliban KNOW they are going to ultimately lose in the USA so they have taken their hatred to Africa. His book IS a lie, it has been proven a lie by several reviewers. Of course, real research & real data mean NOTHING to the fundies.

As to HL, HL insurance covered all of the birth control methods PRIOR to the ACA becoming law. The women who work for HL PAY FOR THEIR INSURANCE through payroll deductions. This ruling means they pay twice. HL gets nearly ALL of the crap they sell from factories in CHINA, a country known for mandated birth control, forced abortions & SLAVE labor. Smart money says that MOST of what HL sells comes from those slave labor factories. HL also makes a TON of money by investing in the pharmaceutical companies that manufacture IUD's, but that is different because it helps them make more money.

Of course, out of sight, out of mind works GREAT for the Green family aka the ultimate example of corporate hypocrisy.

Fundies are the ultimate in selective everything. They wanted to boycott Nabisco because of the Honey Maid Graham Cracker commercials, but still use the internet (basically invented by a gay man). They use their iPhones, post on Facebook & shop at Target. ALL are businesses that support LGBT rights.

The good thing is that every year more Americans realize the harm that these fundies cause & are leaving them behind. Make no mistake, an Americanized, uniquely evangelical form of Sharia law IS here in the USA. The key is to prevent it from growing. There is VERY little difference in the beliefs of extremist Christians & extremists Muslims.

reply

So you hate all fundamentalists because of Scott lively? Alright by your logic, Stalin represents all atheists.
As far as hobby lobby, like many anti Christian bigots, you're all for separation of church and state unless of course it's protecting the church from government as it was intended.
And while religion may be decreasing in the US because of political stances, it's growing tremendously in other parts of the world where believers are being slaughtered. Of course you don't care about them. You only care about your politics. You also don't care that Christian charity and disaster relief constitute a large majority and disaster relief in the world. Liberal hypocrisy is glaring.

reply

Except that poster didn't say any of those things that you are attributing to him/her. Do you know this poster personally or are you just making assumptions and posting them as facts?

There isn't a single thing in your post that reflects what the previous poster wrote. You might want to read it again and set aside any preconceived notions you might have about people with different perspectives than yours. It can help in seeing the points those other people are actually trying to make. And when we do that, we have a much better chance of finding middle ground. And isn't that the goal?

reply

Maybe you read the wrong post. My post was in direct response to lady grey hearts.

reply

Yeah, it looks like he read the right post.

reply

Sorry, but I just have to ask...

When did Hobby Lobby become a church?

I mean, last I heard they are a secular, for profit, American corporation. Period. What exactly does that have to do with "separation of church and state", which pertains to the government NOT showing preference to one faith (which, FYI, the Hobby Lobby case arguably does, as Justice Alito spells out that while HL is entitled to THEIR alleged religious right to not comply with the law -- a law which is equally applied to all corporations without regard to religion -- no other religious company owners are allowed to make the same claim for themselves...what is that except a clear violation of the separation doctrine, as Alito grants fundamentalist Christians he agrees with rights he denies to other faiths?)...

And how's that faith growing in the rest of the world thing working for you? Oh, yeah...religious wars breaking out, murder in the name of faith, all the sins and evils one can imagine, all rationalized and justified in the name of religion! If that's what increased religious belief does, you can keep it!

reply

By your logic, compliance with law takes priority over moral conscience. By your logic, those subject to sharia law should have to obey their government in regards to persecution of homosexuals, atheists, and christians because it is the law. Point being, just because government deems something acceptable, it shouldn't be forced upon those who don't.
Your second point is invalid. I stated Christianity is growing rapidly in countries where it is oppressed. Christianity is not responsible for the oppression you cite. That would be Islam and atheistic communism.

reply

By your logic, compliance with law takes priority over moral conscience. By your logic, those subject to sharia law should have to obey their government in regards to persecution of homosexuals, atheists, and christians because it is the law.


Hi. This is a straw man. I know you haven't been on the Religion board in awhile, but straw men are still lies.

Point being, just because government deems something acceptable, it shouldn't be forced upon those who don't.


No one was forcing anything on Hobby Lobby. The insurance is the employees' compensation. How they use it has nothing to do with Hobby Lobby.

Christianity is not responsible for the oppression you cite. That would be Islam and atheistic communism.


I gave examples of Christian oppression, you lying sack.

reply

You must not understand what a straw man is. My post us directly related to hobby lobby as they're being forced to provide something they feel is wrong. I haven't lied once. Also, I'm not sure where you listed supposed christian oppression, but I can only guess you cited the crusades which were about land and retaliation and the inquisition which was originally started to end false executions and which also targetted Christians. Besides if someone murders inbtge name of Christ, they are still disobeying his teachings. What kind of lunatic would blame Christianity for people disobeying it? Please explain how I've lied.

reply

I'm on mobile..hence typos and no edit.

reply

Well said.

reply

I suggest you educate yourself why those regimes killed believers- it wasn't because the leaders didn't believe in your magic sky-faerie.

It's not as if they were murdering millions in the name of nonbelief. Contrast that to all the hordes of people throughout history who HAVE been killed in the name of a god or gods and you'll see the REAL facts.

reply

Magic sky fairy? Your attempt at insult is trite Dawkins non sense that has no basis in actual scripture. Your infantile post doesn't even deserve a response, but it calls out to be ridiculed and destroyed. You state that one cannot oppress in the name of non belief. This shows a naive, moronic, and simplistic mind set. You view the religious as inferior and a hinderance to society. Dictators have slaughtered millions upon millions for believing they are inferior in some way or the other. You share this mind set with the Klan and Hitler. You fail to see the danger in these bigoted and ignorant mind sets of superiority. It's my opinion some religions have outlandish beliefs, but I won't harrass or mock them because I'm an adult who understands we are all individuals with different experiences.

reply

You fail to see the danger in these bigoted and ignorant mind sets of superiority. It's my opinion some religions have outlandish beliefs, but I won't harrass or mock them because I'm an adult who understands we are all individuals with different experiences.


You're such a liar.

You'll consistently dehumanize atheists. You routinely take a few examples and paint atheists as one monolithic whole. You conflate communism with atheism in order to demonize atheism. You bear as much similarity if not more to the Klan and Hitler.

Take some advice from your holy book. Remove the plank from your eye before pointing out the mote in anothers's.

reply

I've not once lied and its common knowledge that atheism and communism go hand in hand. Once again, please explain how I've lied.

reply

[...]its common knowledge that atheism and communism go hand in hand


Really? I guess "common knowledge" in your parlance refers to those credulous morons that believe the ravings of illiterate, bronze-age, schizophrenic goat-herds over information garnered through the centuries since via the scientific method.

Wake up, ffs - this is the 21st century. Any rational human being has left that 'god' codswallop far behind in the rear-view mirror. The rest are dribbling, gullible buffoons.

Face it, if your parent had told you to worship a flying teapot when you were in your naive childhood, you'd be prostrating yourself before an image of it to this day...

The Adventures of The Man With No Penis: http://tinyurl.com/8ezrkh

reply

Ah condescension and also assumption. Not one valid point was made in your post. Typical of fanatical anti theists.
You presume to know that what every single believers reason for believing is. This is nothing more than bigoted profiling. I believe what I believe because of my personal experiences and the logic/ cohesion of scripture when read in context with am open mind.
Also, you mindlessly spew recycled dawkinisms about bronze age goat herders to discredit as if ideas are limited by age and profession. Of course its another illogical non point that equals "LOL MAGIC SKY FAIRY GOD DONT REAL".
And its absolute fact that atheism and communism go hand in hand. I suggest you study Marxism and the communist regimes of history.

reply

its common knowledge that atheism and communism go hand in hand


Yes. Amongst idiots.

That son of a bitch! Don't get me wrong, he's a fine writer.

reply

And I bare no resemblance to the Klan or Hitler. I don't attack and belittle people for their beliefs as anti theists often do and I care nothing about race. Talk about a strawman and a weak, frivolous, and desperate attack. You failed to even address my point. Hitler believed jews were obsolete and a hinderance to society just as bigoted anti theists believe christianity is. You are delusional if you think that mind set isn't dangerous.

reply

'Jews' are a set of people. 'Christianity' is a creed. Attacking ideas hurts very few in comparison to attacking people. Allowing the latter (when unprovoked) is reprehensible. Allowing the former is necessary for reaching rational conclusions. Your propensity for conflation and presenting false equivalencies knows no bounds, clearly.

reply

[deleted]

Wow you are brain-dead

reply

Pew research earlier this year claims Christians were persecuted in more countries world wide than any other religion, and were the most persecuted religion in the world.

http://www.pewforum.org/2014/01/14/religious-hostilities-reach-six-yea r-high/

Can you find me current examples of Christians persecuting other religious groups that can even come close to the small sample I've posted below?

http://www.cnn.com/2014/05/01/world/asia/china-church-demolished/

http://www.cnn.com/2014/05/15/world/africa/sudan-christian-woman-apost asy/

http://news.yahoo.com/riot-leaves-egyptian-village-without-christians- 193639777.html

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/mar/6/kim-jong-un-calls-execu tion-33-christians/

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2013/dec/22/persecutio n-christians-middle-east-prince-charles

reply

And yet none of those countries are the US are they? I would also point out that two of the links you posted are about Christians in Muslim countries, AKA countries where Islam is the official religion. Two of the other links are from communist countries and the last one is in the middle of a war that has been raging for years and years.

reply

Damnit I need to get out of this trap of a thread but I can't help myself. The OP made direct reference to Uganda(Africa, but he meant the Uganda fiasco of course), why does this poster's reply have to be U.S. specific?

reply

Thank you. OP talked about Africa and Nazi Germany - those aren't the US! Does the Hobby Lobby "persecution" come anywhere close to what I've provided links to?

reply

The OP also wasn't limited to people targeted because of their religion, but you conveniently ignored that.

reply

Because the whole plot of this movie centers on persecution of Christians in the US.

reply

Can you find me current examples of Christians persecuting other religious groups that can even come close to the small sample I've posted below?


http://www.commdiginews.com/world-news/in-tragic-twist-anti-balaka-chr istian-terror-groups-attack-african-muslims-9691/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Liberation_Front_of_Tripura

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-25216351

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/feb/14/muslim-convoy-central-afr ican-republic-exodus

http://www.globalresearch.ca/france-and-the-militarization-of-central- africa-thousands-of-muslims-fleeing-the-central-african-republic/53692 76

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Norway_attacks

reply

The anti theists do not care about facts and humanism. They only care about their fanatical doctrine.

reply

The anti theists do not care about facts and humanism. They only care about their fanatical doctrine.


Ah, Reallussion, still a fan of projection and hypocrisy.

reply

Where have I shown to be a hypocrite? I haven't attacked anyone for what they believe or did believe. I talked about anti theists.

reply

I am a devout Christian and I think that was very well said. Bravo.

reply

There are a lot of posts on this board that deserve applause....




"My Little Throny! I used to wonder what bloodshed could be..."

reply

It happens every time. These posts have zero to do with the movie which most of us have not seen. I will probably watch it when it comes out on video. Probably as part of my Netflix subscription. My impression is that this is a controversial movie, meaning that no one can be objective about it. That said, the likelihood that it is not a very good movie seems great.

My own thoughts on the persecution of Christians and related topics: The notion that Christians could become persecuted in this country in the near future is an exaggeration. What we are seeing, though, is a tendency to vilify some Christians and use them as a whipping boy to drum up support for leftist initiatives usually based on unlikely fantasies themselves (view the notion expressed here that Christians are in any position to persecute non-Christians). And it is not just the media that does the vilifying but some politicians and bureaucrats. As to Sharia law, there are moves to recognize the practice of Sharia by Muslims within non-Muslim countries, and this raises issues about where to draw the line because some religious courts would like to make rules about all areas of life whereas secular courts would prefer to reserve the right to deal with life and death matters, for example.

A better grounded exploration of the issue of religious liberty would be gained if we had movies--either documentary or fictionalized--about persecution of Christians in other countries which is definitely both a historical and current problem. In Asia, Africa and the Middle East this is happening now. Nazis might have claimed to have God on their side, but they probably also thought that Hitler was God's representative. (Hitler himself thought so.) The Nazis coopted Christian religions during the thirties and forties, having luck with most except for Jehovah's Witnesses and a small Protestant coalition called the Confessing Church. Imperial Japan, during the same period, also coopted most religions except for--once again--Jehovah's Witnesses--and Nichiren Shoshu, a sort of Buddhist equivalent of Jehovah's Witnesses. This little known story of religious persecution would make a great movie. The Imperial government told Christians they would have to put Imperial symbols on their altars and that there were too many Christian religions so many of the Protestant sects were forced to merge (So were many Buddhist sects). In both Germany and Japan, religious people went to prison for resisting these types of measures.

reply

"If it was not for Christians and people of faith, evil would dominate. Are you ready for Sharia law?"

That comment is dripping with irony.

reply

I understand you want to attack Christians and that's fine, people like us that are left of center or left of left usually take any opportunity to jump them. But we are starting to lose every argument because of arguments that start and end like yours did. We need to understand what each group believes and what they do not believe. Their differences if you will. We speak in slogans and now argue in blanket statements which is fine if they were as stupid as we thought but they supported the Iraq & Afghanistan wars, which conversely means they know the what separates the Sun ni from the Shia muslims. They answer slogans and insults in debated paragraphs now so, help us all out- us being tne left. Stop attacking just until you can be literate in your debate. Also, not the bog picture but larger than what is going on with this...it's a movie. There are more important things than this to be confrontational about. This is a waste of time and words. I hope this helps you re-focus on something more than middle age people seeing a bad movie. I hope these words help you help the left instead of hurting us by being petty and uneducated about this subject
.

reply