MovieChat Forums > Emergo (2012) Discussion > My Explanation (MAJOR SPOILERS!!!)

My Explanation (MAJOR SPOILERS!!!)


First off, I have to say that this is possibly one of the best films in this found footage genre. The more I think about the film, the more amazed I am at the complexity of the story telling. Yes, it may not be the most original in terms of visuals and execution, but it certainly has a very original plot and plot twist at the end. Here's why I think that...

********SPOILERS START HERE********

1. With regards to the unexplained goings-on in the apartment, anyone who's seen the film knows that the doctor is full of BS. But it's a much needed BS to throw us off from the final scene, which in my opinion explains a whole lot. More on that later. The doctor was integral, the "Scully" if you will ("X-Files" shout out!).

2. From the doctor's perspective, the banging, the voices, the flying stuff, the levitation, all stem from the teenage girl's resentment towards her father. She blames him for her mother's death, as well as (seemingly) molesting her. By the doctor's own theory stated somewhere in the middle of the film, tragedy and awful events tend to leave an echo and has a desire to be discovered (the whole "the truth will always come out" idea) even through unexplained phenomena. His first theory is that the father killed the mother and molested her daughter, and those truths are trying to be discovered.

3. The doctor then changes his tune when he interrogates the father, and it's revealed that the dead mother is schizophrenic and was a horrible woman after she stopped taking her medication. After discovering his wife with another man, while their daughter was watching, he takes the kids and flees. She goes after him and crashes her car, ending up dead. This is a very important plot point that would explain my final theory.

4. After the truth of the dead wife's mental illness comes out, the doctor then theorizes that everything happening is merely a physical manifestation of the daughter's rage, and ultimately, her mental illness as inherited from the mother. Taking a cue from "X-Men", I believe that the doctor postulates that because of adolescent hormones coupled with a tragic event, the daughter is able to do all of the things they experienced in the apartment. Now, of course that's a bit of a stretch, but the doctor concludes that there is no ghost, but there certainly is something not normal going on, but it's all part of the phenomena of the mystery of the brain. And a sick brain is capable of strange things. So by the end, we are led to believe that there is no ghost activity, but rather a yet-unexplained scientific activity is to blame. Ghosts don't exist, but powerful mental abilities do.

5. Then there's the final image. Some of you have called it cheesy, but to me, it actually rebukes all of the scientific hypotheses laid out for us to believe. Then the wheels in my brain started turning and the explanation (as derived by me, not to be taken as fact) turns out to be more chilling and sinister than I thought.

6. Yes, the ghost was real. Yes, it was the dead wife. And yes, she's pissed. Pissed at her husband for abandoning her. Pissed that she's dead. And that anger led her to want the worst for her husband. And what's the worst thing you can do to a father? Make it look like he was molesting his teenage daughter. Yes, I believe that the dead mom was trying to frame the father to get him sent to jail and ruin his life. The lifting of the nightgown, the possessed daughter screaming "You know what you did! To the girl!!!", and the smirk at the end of the final possession all point to her thinking she succeeded. Only, she didn't, hence the final appearance at the end. Consider it a last ditch attempt at being heard.

I'm curious to see if anyone else came up with this conclusion.

So, like I said, I cannot say enough about how much I think this film to be one of the best films, not just in found-footage horror, but in horror in general. It's one that makes you think, instead of just handing over every plot point on a silver platter. Plus, the green strobe-light scene made me scream out loud, and I haven't done that in YEARS! Horror films don't scare me that much (I saw "The Exorcist" when I was five and just went "Meh..." Now, I think it's an amazing piece of cinema) but this one certainly did. Highly recommended!

reply

That green strobelight scene was seizure inducing, but I didn't want to take my eyes off because I know something was going to happen.

reply

I don't think ghost was trying to frame him. Even it was that savvy, ghost can't testify in court nor are the investigators going to testify to ghost hearsay though that would make a better movie.

L7world.com Columbus was Wrong!

reply

"6. Yes, the ghost was real. Yes, it was the dead wife. And yes, she's pissed. Pissed at her husband for abandoning her. Pissed that she's dead. And that anger led her to want the worst for her husband. And what's the worst thing you can do to a father? Make it look like he was molesting his teenage daughter. Yes, I believe that the dead mom was trying to frame the father to get him sent to jail and ruin his life. The lifting of the nightgown, the possessed daughter screaming "You know what you did! To the girl!!!", and the smirk at the end of the final possession all point to her thinking she succeeded. Only, she didn't, hence the final appearance at the end. Consider it a last ditch attempt at being heard. "

nice. however, she probably was not trying to frame him initially, but replay his actions on the daughter to drive him crazy. in front of company, it could be seen as framing. whatever the case, she is totally pissed off and is getting back at the husband.

reply

Make it look like he was molesting his teenage daughter. Yes, I believe that the dead mom was trying to frame the father


Why didn't she possess the daughter, seduce the father, and then frame him? Stupid ghost.


\\\ http://TheMovieGoer.com ///

///Twitter.com/TheMovieGoer\\\

reply

wtf... you think it's actually easy for a daughter to seduce her own father?

...in front of those cameras????

i wonder who's stupid.

reply

you think it's actually easy for a daughter to seduce her own father?


think? I know it is you dolt, if the crazy mother ghost wanted to.



\\\ http://TheMovieGoer.com ///

///Twitter.com/TheMovieGoer\\\

reply

It's widely known among psychiatric experts that schizophrenic ghosts who've stopped taking their meds aren't exactly the most cunning and forward thinking of criminals.

But if I was the dad, it would've been easy for that daughter to seduce me. Spooky eyes or not.

reply

coffeeboy,

IMO, this was one of the worst examples of the found-footage film genre. It made me laugh (such as when the father is prodded into wailing "She was a F####G WH@@E!! & then added she had stopped cleaning herself & was "stinking" - Huh?). Hysterical.

But if you enjoyed it, good for you. For a GOOD & CREEPY found-footage film, check out LAKE MUNGO. Watch it late at night. Alone...

;)

reply

It made me laugh (such as when the father is prodded into wailing "She was a F####G WH@@E!! & then added she had stopped cleaning herself & was "stinking" - Huh?). Hysterical.

I thought the father's confession was done very well and it was very convincing.





Hey Linda..........You're a bitch!

reply

Me too. I thought his acting in that scene was very convincing.

I simply am not there...

reply

I really did begin to suspect the father of either having molested his daughter, or having witnessed her molested by someone else when she was a child and didn't do anything about it. I thought about this after the scene where the daughter gets possessed and the ghost is pissed at the father for what he did to "the girl". I also felt concerned about the scene where the daughter did not want her father touching at AT ALL. Or, the dead wife could've just made it look like the father harmed his daughter in that way. The whole lifting the nightgown, and saying what she said while possessing her daughter.

Might I add, the last shot of the movie where the wife crawls on the ceiling towards the camera scared the living daylights out of me. I actually knew it would happen, so I managed to cover my eyes just as the camera was panning to the ceiling. Ugh... But the light flashing scene, too, when she appears on the wall, made me jump so badly!! :( I made myself watch that scene even though I suspected it would happen...

reply

LOL, teen angst didn't begin with the X-Men. That's actually a classic "explanation" for poltergeists.

reply

None of it was real. The movie was about actors creating a paranormal type movie. Very clever. The actors were playing actors. A found footage movie production within a movie. I feel dumb for not seeing this earlier

reply

I don't think the doctor ever believed the dad was the bad guy, the Irish female technician is the one who thought the dad killed the wife IIRC. The doctor however knew about the wife's mental illness and the dad wanting a divorce, that's why he forced the husband into a confession.

reply

Watch it again, but keep an eye on the continuity errors.
So many that actually that it cant be mistakes by the editors... it was done on purpose.
I posted a few of the obvious examples here... http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1757742/board/thread/242446441

But i'm telling you i could probably list out a continuity error every 5 mins of this movie. Its quite a clever concept for the movie, made me chuckle once i started to see it. It's like they are trying to tell you every 5 mins... this is a scam. Still makes me chuckle as i think back to it.

reply