I can't bring myself to see this movie....

The trailer only tells you a little bit. There's a huge key to the plot left out that is awesome because if it was shown in the trailer it would ruin the whole movie.

From the trailer I get the impression that Blunt's character has 'Friend Zoned' her male buddy and once he spends an evening of passion with her sister she starts getting worried that her shoulder to cry on, go to listener will no longer be at her beck and call.

I'd really like to see this flick, but I do hope he tells them both where to stick it.
.....or....Threesome!

Just kidding....or am I?

IMDB - Because some trolls need more than just a bridge

Both sisters don't "fall for" Jack. Only Iris does. She has been friends with him for years. He used to have his sh!t together, but has been depressed since his brother died, which is very understandable (his brother is his only sibling and they were close). At the beginning of the film, Iris points out that Jack has been different since his brother died and she misses the way he used to be. She sends him off to her father's secluded cabin so he can have some alone time and straighten himself out. When he arrives, he finds her sister Hannah there. She is depressed about the end of an unstable seven-year relationship. Jack and Hannah get drunk and decide to have sex. Neither of them has any romantic feelings for the other and they both regret their drunken tryst. Jack is in love with Iris and Iris is in love with Jack, but she used to date his brother so they're both afraid it will be awkward if they expose their feelings.

It's not like they both fall for him at first sight. Iris (Emily Blunt's character) is secretly in love with him, but they've been friends for a long time. Even though he's depressed and doesn't have his sh!t together, he and Iris have a comfortable, easy rapport and they make each other laugh. She also remembers what he was like before his brother died and he became depressed. I can see how her character could have fallen for him over time. Hannah (Rosemarie Dewitt's character) doesn't even fall for him. She just gets drunk with him and then they have a one night stand.

Mark Duplass is EXTREMELY charismatic and is actually pretty attractive. He's just not your average over the top ridiculously good looking actor that Hollywood shoves down our throats. I think he has a very refreshing face and personality.
Plus he makes quality films. This film in particular has his best dramatic acting to date. The film is also very funny. I say don't miss it people! (I also hated My Effortless Brilliance)

Did you even see the movie? It doesn't sound like you did.

I personally liked Duplass but I have a propensity for cute, somewhat nerdy guys. And since his character is unhinged by his brother's death, I take it that Iris - Emily Blunt's character - knew enough of him and his true nature before he got messed up and directionless.

My problem with the movie was the lack of the two people talking about the brother. It seemed more like a convenient framing device and then....poof!

the film was shot with a 70 page script. Do some research (or maybe even see the goddamn movie) before making claims like that.

"If a guy doesn't look like a *beep* Adonis, then he'll never get laid." - You, paraphrased

Your life sounds awful.

The knack to flying lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss.

I thought he had charisma and personally I like a man on the larger, nonperfect side. Cuddly and slightly rumpled. They seem more real and sexy to me than buffed up, macho, every hair in place perfect looking men. I didn't see him as a loser either, just someone still dealing with grief from the loss of a loved one. I liked all three main characters in this, especially him.

When you get up in the morning, how do you decide what shade of black to wear? (Shallow Grave)

Point of order: the lesbian didn't fall for him, he was just her sperm donor.