MovieChat Forums > Secret in Their Eyes (2015) Discussion > Why do people keep praising the original...

Why do people keep praising the original so much?


The original was overrated, chock full of cliches. I can recommend several much better foreign thrillers:

1. The Hidden Face (do not watch trailer b/c it reveals the shocking twist)
2. Sleep Tight
3. Tell No One
4. With A Friend Like Harry
5. Head-On

All of these are much better and less predictable; especially "The Hidden Face" which contains probably the most-surprising twist I've ever seen.

reply

The original was overrated, chock full of cliches. I can recommend several much better foreign thrillers:
Well...just for the record, the original movie does NOT get recommended as a thriller. It's kind of in a category/genre all by itself, but it might best be grouped as a romance wrapped around a police drama with comedy elements.

Now THIS film, the "remake", tries to go an altogether different direction. It is more of a thriller/mystery with a romantic subplot.

Peace! 


On November 6, 2012 god blessed America...again. 

reply

It's the same when ppl say "the book is sooo much better than the movie/tv show".

They saw/read X so everything else is subpar compared to it. It's impossible for them to appreciate X at the same time as Y.

reply

Wow, 5, huh?

How many better English language thrillers can you list than this trash?

___
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qssvnjj5Moo

reply

You are right on with these especially The Hidden Face! I've never seen anything like it.

reply