MovieChat Forums > Wu xia (2011) Discussion > Wu Xia + Sherlock Holmes

Wu Xia + Sherlock Holmes


Does anyone else see the similarities between Wu Xia and Guy Ritchie's Sherlock Holmes? I'm particularly noticing the first action sequence in Wu Xia, where events are dissected and replayed as the detective investigates the evidence.

Actually. Both sort of seemed to lift some style from the CSI television shows...

I wrote some about this here: http://www.standbyformindcontrol.com/2012/11/explosive-wu-xia-action/

reply

A very superficial similarity. Probably not worth bothering with.

reply

Yea In fact I thought it was an Asian combo of

A history of violence and Sherlock Holmes


reply

In a book about director Peter Chan, he said: "At one point in the script development phase, someone pointed out that the plot resembled an episode of CSI. I was inclined to agree despite never having seen the show. To me, House was the more obvious influence - Takeshi Kaneshiro’s character was definitely inspired by Dr. Gregory House."

reply