MovieChat Forums > The Bay (2012) Discussion > The Huge Plot Hole That Isn't, Really (S...

The Huge Plot Hole That Isn't, Really (SPOILERS)


How the hell does everyone come down simultaneously with the isopod infection, and on July 4, to boot? If larvae had been in the drinking water, you would have seen a gradual ramping up of cases over an extended period of time, not 700 infections the first day of the epidemic.

As it so happens, this is trivial to explain, so trivial that I suspect the explanation was in the script and maybe was even shot, but then omitted from the final cut.

It's pretty clear that someone at the de-salination plant screwed up the water filtration so that it failed at about midnight the night before the 4th, allowing the larvae into the town water supply. It takes 8 hours for the larvae to grow into adults, so the first victims become symptomatic at noon, having been early birds who drank tap water at 4 AM. And that there would be a screwup right before the holiday is credible, because maybe the worker was distracted by holiday plans.

I'm guessing that they decided that they could cut all of this out of the movie because, after all, none of it is scary in itself ... but it would have made the film more credible and hence scarier for people (like me) who notice scientific plot holes. I figured out the above while driving home from the theater ... but while I was watching it, it didn't ring true as a real epidemic to me.

Prepare your minds for a new scale of physical, scientific values, gentlemen.

reply

[deleted]

i just thought it was kinda funny seeing how the CDC office looked like a cheap rented out lease office kitchen. it also seems like Asian people were immune to the parasites since i dont recall seeing one Asian person dead in the movie or any Asians for that matter. also the CDC using google to search for images of these isopods was pretty lame. im pretty sure the real CDC has its own resources for doing research...

reply

That works fine as an explanation for the people who drank the tap water, but what about the bay itself? Are we supposed to believe that in the 16 days between the divers' deaths and the fourth of July, NO ONE went swimming in the bay? Even if they were far enough out into the water to not affect people swimming on the beach, there was obviously an active boating community in the town. It doesn't make sense there would be no cases before then.

reply

It was America not China you dolt.

http://TheMovieGoer.com

reply

What bothered me was when the Cameraman washes his face in the kiddy pool he dies, yet when the reporter washes her face later in the fountain after being covered in a victim's blood she's okay, just struck me as odd.

reply

And she took a break from reporting to drink from a fountain!

reply

She says at the end that some people were immune but she didn't know why. She was one of them.

reply