MovieChat Forums > The Bay (2012) Discussion > Do the film makers know anything about b...

Do the film makers know anything about biology?


So...was this supposed to be a virus or a parasite? It began looking like a viral/bacterial outbreak of some sort and then came down to the parasites. The symptoms were off for the kind of parasite infection they were portraying. You could argue that there was a virus/bacteria in the water as well, but that's never really expanded upon. All in all, it would have been better if it was more realistic. I went in expecting a horror movie and when it was more of a found footage disaster movie, I shifted gears and hoped for more realism.

reply

The science in this was solid. If you paid attention it was both a "parasite" and a virus. The virus (vibrio vulnificus) and its blistering symptoms are very real. Drinking contaminated water or ingesting a tiny parasite like the ones in the film can cause this type of infection. Likewise, the rapid growth of the isopods due to the steroid-laiden nutrient pollution happens on a daily basis, perhaps not as exaggerated as in this movie, but certainly not out of the question.

The amount of correct science in this film is what makes the conceit so terrifying.

reply

The science was actually pretty horrible. On top of that, the doctors are all idiots. 30 people come in with obviously contagious conditions and he doesn't think to even put on a face mask or gloves. It was absolutely ridiculous.

reply

I was laughing at the biologists at the beginning. They were touching the algae with laced with bacteria with no gloves on.

reply

First , I would like to say that I enjoyed this movie.

Now for the science:
The tongue parasite, Cymothoa exigua
The giant isopod, Bathynomus giganteus
Both are from the order Isopoda, suborder Cymothoida - they simply belong to different family and genus. So, to say they are completely different isn't completely correct.
The smaller tongue parasite as portrayed in the fish on film is very close to accurate. All but the harmful effect to the fish. They attach to the gills an migrate to the tongue , replacing it for the duration of the fish's lifespan.
The larger giant isopod is mainly a deep sea scavenger , however it is also a carnivorous predator and has been known to adopt parasitic tendancies.

Many other species over human history have been thought to only exist as parasites or bacteria in the animal kingdom only to be discovered in an infected human patient. As a matter of fact, most of the serious outbreaks in history have come from animal-human cross contamination.

Therefore it is not a scientific stretch to think that these species either through a natural imperative or human meddling could in fact become the threat seen in this movie.



*
Miskatonic University - Go Pods !!!

reply

I've always thought that tongue parasite was cute and used to want a few as pets. I never expect movies to be realistic, but there could have been both a parasite and viral/bacterial infection affecting people.

Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt.

reply

The "biology" was good enough for most laypersons looking to be entertained.

I don't love her.. She kicked me in the face!!

reply