Titanic: Blood and Steel......Such good promise, but bad ending

I would guess that the reason why it was not continued through the illfated voyage and sinking was $$$$$. To do it right and with the same visuals and effects that most would expect, the budget would have to had been increased several fold. Any TITANIC movie from now on will, for better or worse, be compared to Cameron's bloated film. While the story in Cameron's work was cliched and the acting was questionalble at best, even detractors (like myself) will give him credit of making a visually fantastic movie.

The least they could have done was given an epologue... what happened to the people.

Of characters (both real or ficitional) we saw that were on the ship, we can say for certain the fate of some:

Historical characters:
- Capt. Smith: Died
- Thomas Andrews: Died
- J.Bruce Ismay: Survived

Two of the Fictional characters we can pretty say for certain:
- Dr.Mark Muir / Marcus Malone: Died (none of the Guarentee Group survived)
- ??? (the young Harland and Wolff worker, last person listed on the Guarentee Group list) Died (same raeson as above)

Other fictioanl characters that we saw we can make an educated guess:
If travelling first class, Kitty Carlton and Joanna probably survived (Historically, Ida Strauss and Edith Evans, Bessie Allison and Ann Isham were the only four first class ladies to be lost). If travelling second class, they had an 86% chance of survival.

As for the characters in third class, there was a 46% Chance that the women survived (Sophia and Violetta and I will throw in her baby too) and a 16% chance that the men survived (Michael).

As for the crew (Andrea was shown as part of the "black gang" / stoker), it is hard to tell... 23% of the crew survived... but the stokers were well below decks... though some of firemen/stokers did survive, including lead firman Fred Barret).


====
Not even if Hell freezes over and they play The Stanley Cup down there.

Agreed. Some here don't seem to mind, but for me it was a cheesy ending.

I like that they ended it where they did. It leaves it open for interpretation (or a possible second season, although given the budget, I doubt it), rather than the bitter reality that almost all the characters will be dead in a week. This way, we get to imagine that Michael survives. My real sorrow for them not continuing is no series/movie has ever dealt with the aftermath before, and I would like to see THIS Thomas Andrews deal with the collision and sinking, and the enormous impact it has on Harland & Wolff and the White Star Line.

---------------------------
www.charitysplace.com

Respectfully, I don't understand your, "left you hanging" comment, nor the "ambiguous ending" comment by another poster in this thread. Really, who doesn’t already know the ending? While I agree the series ended too quickly, it was very fitting. However, I’ll also agree that an epilogue would’ve been an enhancement.

How many movies and documentaries have already been produced about the sailing & sinking? For this production to go there again would've been redundant and would’ve been compared to the numerous recreations of the ending already out there *. And in my humble opinion would’ve been an insult to our capacity to simply know and understand what happens next… having heard and watched THAT PART of the story so many times already.

Blood & Steel ended just where it should have because it was the story of BUILDING Titanic. I would suggest that it was meant to go no further and as such, fills a void in the telling of Titanic’s history that has not been covered before. That's why I found it so fascinating - it brought to life that part of Titanic's history which is fresh and relatively ignored - and knew enough to stop there.

* Given the way they outright ignored the existence of the Olympic in the first episode, then the fictional way by which they injected Olympic into later episodes infers a lack of historical credibility. If they did produce an additional episode to cover the sailing and sinking, I would bet, given the plethora of other productions out there, it would be a definite challenge to compare favorably.

I watched the marathon yesterday and couldn't believe they wouldn't tell us what happened to everyone that left on the ship. Admittedly, it was tremendously poignant to see them all boarding the ship full of hope for the future and knowing what they were heading into. I think though they could've done maybe one more episode perhaps from the point of view of those left back in Dublin finding out about the sinking and waiting to hear. It wouldn't have cost as much as filming the sinking and could've wrapped things up nicely, but I guess the makers wanted to leave us all to wonder and hope.

Very sad that Mark/Marcus probably wouldn't have survived as a member of the Guarantee Group but you just can see him making sure Sofia got into a lifeboat and promising to see her soon.

[deleted]

My DVR absolutely will not stop recording this thing, each time it comes on, despite my repeated attempts to cancel it. I must have a Poltergeist who gets a kick out of my frustration!

Watching this series, last fall, was one of the more frustrating of my viewing experiences over the last 40 years. I thought the beginning was slow and they had a few too many angles going at the same time, but I stuck with it and became rather fond of some of the characters. I was rather enjoying the prospects of the Mark Muir character, which was totally fictitious, finding his biological daughter. It would have been extremely unusual, back then, for that to have happened, and I am speaking as someone who has helped four of my own children locate their birth parents. It isn't that easy, even now.

Anyway, with the ship finally underway, I was anxious to see what was going to happen. Obviously, many people were going to die, but it seemed that there would also have been some happy endings, and some inspiring acts of selflessness. I couldn't believe they were ending it there! If it was the story of almost any other transatlantic crossing, it would have been easy to just believe that all of the characters would find a better life in America.

But, who are Earth would have thought it was good entertainment to end a miniseries with "Oh well, they worked hard to get on that boat to America but now most of them are just going to freeze to death in the middle of the night".

Obviously, a great deal of money was sunk into that production. I would bet that it cost them millions just to get Chris Noth to appear as JP Morgan, in a few scenes. Either they better reassemble that cast, follow those characters through the crossing and come up with at least a few happy endings, or this is going to go down in my memory as one of the biggest wastes of time ever!

I completely agree with you. It would have been wonderful to have some closure. Even if it was just a few lines of text under the faces of the characters at the end. And I read somewhere that they just officially announced that there would be no second season which is a total opportunity missed if you ask me. They could have had an episode or two about the sinking, and then had like for or five about the aftermath and proceedings. It would have especially been amazing I think if somehow Muir would have lived (unlikely as it is) and using his expertise explained the situation, how it happened and then having him have something to do with the changes made to the Olymipic and later the Britanic. But idk honestly I was just upset with the ambiguity