MovieChat Forums > New York'ta Bes Minare (2010) Discussion > Worst Ever !

Worst Ever !

posted 13 years ago by urgenc2003-636-216867
21 replies | jump to latest

This movie is probably the worst movie ever in Turkish history of cinema. How do you spend 11 million dollars on a movie budget and f.ck up with every aspect of cinema culture ? Plainly this is a movie about Fetullah Gulen and an attempt on putting a curtain over his ciminality. Its the first and last time I will go to a movie associated with Mahsun Kirmizigul. And looking at the budget I see how he was sponsored by Muslim extremists and accomplice.

Although I'm a very open minded person ,this movie has frustrated me in many ways. Don't go to this movie !

[–] akinsamsun 13 years ago

As an open minded person you are, could you please let us know what crimes has Mr. Gulen committed?

[–] urgenc2003-636-216867 13 years ago

Please define "us" ?

[–] CaptainTurco 13 years ago

'us' probably means the readers, u dumb *beep*

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] akinsamsun 13 years ago

So what?
i haven`t asked about the quality of the movie, have i?
i just wanted know the crimes that you said Mr. Gulen has committed.
You know any correct crime? or you are just trying to manipulate people`s thoughts about a person over the net with nonsense accusations just to get them believe what you made up, and hate him as you do?

other than that i have not seen the movie yet, but you probaply right about the quality of it, when we consider what Mahsun has done until this one.

if you do not understand what i meant to say, please do not hesitate to ask.

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] akinsamsun 13 years ago

and your proof for your argument?

What has he done against Turkish Republic?

[–] LosMagandos76 13 years ago

"The existing system is still in power. Our friends who have positions in legislative and administrative bodies should learn its details and be vigilant all the time so that they can transform it and be more fruitful on behalf of Islam in order to carry out a nationwide restoration" - F. Gulen on replacing the Turkish Secular System.

Turkey is Secular, and it will STAY SECULAR.

"If the milk turns out to be sour, I ain't the kinda pussy to drink it." -Mr Rory Breaker

[–] murad23 13 years ago

We are "sucular" in the sense we ethically cleansed out all the other religions!
And the cult of personality around Ataturk, aroudn which there are fake legends and cover ups galore qualifies as a religion

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] dumbmage 13 years ago

take a chill pill every1, this is a movie forum...

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] djhuso 13 years ago

" how he was sponsored by Muslim extremists"

For bitches like u, everyone who believes in Allah and his messenger is a terrorist, so keep watching movies like rambo and other pentagon sponsored crap and don't bother us with your hatery, fool

[–] iayazalp 13 years ago

The movie was pretty ok, but i wont recommend it to people...

There is no action like you would expect from the trailer... The only action you see is in the first 5 minutes...

There are some dialogues where i asked myself "is this nescesary?"
The voiceover from the americans was plainly bad.

The final twist was kinda explained in the rooftop scene somewhere half of the movie... but I liked the actual twist at the end of the movie...

The acting was good even for turkish standards....

Like I said, its an OK movie, but i wont recommend because i know not everyone will appreciate it.

[–] szisoman 13 years ago

I like the way bigots like you show their abject ignorance, Nazis would be proud of you.

" I am talking about..ethics "

[–] CanGuclu 13 years ago

I totally agree with you.

Don't mind what the others say, you see the truth and so do I, so we should just stay away from Mahsun's movies.

AKA: CanGuclu

[–] ShirinShirinShirin 13 years ago

I respect your opinion on the film (everyone is entitled to their own) what I find disturbing; however, is your vehement desire to bar anyone else from seeing it. And honestly, "worst movie in the history of Turkish cinema?" Pft... are you serious? Either you havn't seen many films or maybe what you really meant was "most disagreeable political message i've come across in Turkish cinema" when you critique a FILM it has many elements not just the PLOT/SCRIPT it has cinematic effects, actors, soundtracks, costume, set, cinematography etc... and yet you have reduced this film to it's plot and labeled it 'the worst' in the history of Turkish cinema... I havn't even watched it yet but I can already tell you're not very 'open minded' at all.

[–] dumbmage 13 years ago

indeed. u can't teach a bigot because he think he already know everything there is to know about anything that's worth knowing :)

i also remind you, don't waste ur breathe. as a wise man once said;

arguing on internet is like running in special olympics. even if u win, u're still retarded ;)

[–] Snugglygirl 13 years ago

The only worse thing ever about the movie were the ignorant people sitting behind my husband and me.

When the scene with the Black Americans was playing, one of the guys said a racial slur and said he will never go into that neighborhood (stupid people take movies too literally).