Question


First off, what a phenomenal movie. Wonderful acting all along, I was crying by the end.

I have a question that may come off as ignorant-- I admit I'm not thoroughly well-versed on the details of AIDS and its methods of transmission, so I apologize if I offend.

How did Ned not get infected? He had a sexual partner with AIDS, and there didn't seem to be any condom use happening based on the reaction to the doctor's suggestion during that meeting. Was it just luck?

reply

Some had stronger immune systems than their partners even though they were still infected. If you saw Longtime Companion, David was healthy when his partner (his name escapes me), but he eventually died from AIDS

reply

Just because Ned appeared healthy during the movie doesn't mean he wasn't infected. I believe at that time there still wasn't a blood test to check for HIV, you were assumed to be healthy until you developed the purple lesions or in Craig's case, respiratory symptoms. We never saw Nick's lover become ill either although he died fairly early in the movie.

Larry Kramer is working on the sequel to The Normal Heart which centers on Ned Weeks and his battle after he is diagnosed as HIV positive.

reply

Just because Ned appeared healthy during the movie doesn't mean he wasn't infected. I believe at that time there still wasn't a blood test to check for HIV, you were assumed to be healthy until you developed the purple lesions or in Craig's case, respiratory symptoms. We never saw Nick's lover become ill either although he died fairly early in the movie.

Larry Kramer is working on the sequel to The Normal Heart which centers on Ned Weeks and his battle after he is diagnosed as HIV positive.


Furthermore, Ned is based on Larry Kramer himself--and Kramer has been HIV-positive for over 25 years (he was diagnosed in the late 1980s).

reply

Not everyone who is exposed will become infected. Some that do may not become ill.

Think about it in terms of the plague. Many died, some became ill and recovered, and quite a few never became ill at all. Those of use with ancestors from the areas that were affected are descendants of the survivors. It's a bit of natural gene selection.

CCR5-delta 32 is a mutated gene and it's believed those who have it are HIV/AIDS resistant. It's being studied in the research for treatments and the cure.

There are now medications that can make the viral load undetectable. There are also meds. that one can take as a precaution if in a high risk position. Safe sex though is still advised.

The immune aspect of it isn't as bad as it once was. There are now much more treatments for that. Effects from inflammation are now what is of the highest concern for those living with HIV?AIDS.

reply

Don't you think that there may be already a cure for hiv AIDS out there but not released because it would be a massive blow to the big pharmaceutical companies?

For them hiv AIDS is a blessing as anyone who's gets it has to take medication for the rest of the their lives to keep the virus at bay.

I guess if we do ever see a cure for hiv AIDS that just means there is something much worse on the horizon...

reply

At the end of the movie, you see that Ned's rolodex card is being removed and put in the pile of cards of those that had died previously. That tells me that he eventually died of AIDS.

reply

No. I was wrong. Ned didn't get sick or died at the end of the movie. Sorry!!

reply