A Downward Spiral in Graphic Form

I don't think you know what a sociopath is.

I do. You obviously do not. How about instead of telling me that I don't know what a sociopath is, you provide some documented evidence that shows that I am wrong? And how about you tell me point by point how I am wrong since you are convinced I am?

Sociopath is a term that is used coloqially to describe antisocial personality disorder (http://www.mcafee.cc/Bin/sb.html). It is an axis II diagnosis that generally forms in adolescence. In order to have a diagnosis, you have to meet specific criteria as outlined in the DSM. These work this way:

First necessary criteria:

Three or more of these traits must be present:

1. Repeated acts that lead to multiple arrests. There was no indication of this in Alyce's life.
2. Conning people and using aliases repeatedly and lying about one's identity (Despite the claims of SWF similarity, there is no evidence that this was done throughout Alyce's life, only after Carroll was hurt).
3. Failure to plan ahead or be compulsive. This was not shown in any manner to be consistent enough to be considered abnormal.
4. Repeated assaults on others. Although this happens after Carroll's injury, there is no indication that this was something that Alyce did before meeting Carroll. Her attacks generally had purpose as well.
5. Reckless when it comes to one's safety or safety of others. Although the rooftop thing was reckless, Alyce and Carroll were on drugs and there was no indication that Alyce experienced these symptoms before the injury.
6. Poor work behavior or failure to honor financial obligations. No indication of this anywhere in the movie.
7. Rationalizing the pain inflicted upon others. Maybe, but she didn't defend her actions.

The second necessary criteria is that they are at least 18 years old. She is.

The third necessary criteria is that she has evidence of conduct disorder before the age of 15. Without this, a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder cannot be made. No indication of this is mentioend in the film. Conduct disorder is not as simple as behavior problems. Rather than explain it, here is a research article (http://www.aacap.org/aacap/Families_and_Youth/Facts_for_Families/Facts_for_Families_Pages/Conduct_Disorder_33.aspx)

The fourth necessary criteria is that the symptoms cannot be due to another mental disorder. The information needed to prove this is not given in the film.

A sociopath would not have been upset when her friend was injured and would not have been upset when she found out Carroll was alive. Their relationships mean nothing more beyond their designation as a friendship. They have no real feelings for people they are involved with. They do not let past events or future events affect their thinking, thereby never planning ahead (Alyce did).

Furthermore, since antisocial personality disorder has to have conduct order present before the age of 15, it is therefore IMPOSSIBLE for someone to develop antisocial personality disorder at the age that Alyce is in the movie.

So how about before you come on this site and tell someone they don't know what they are talking about, you do a little research to show that you do know what you're talking about. I know what a sociopath is, you obviously do not.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

Just to clarify: Alyce wasn't 'raped' by that guy Rex..she voluntarily consented to have sex with him in exchange for drugs. She may not have been happy about it, and it doesn't make him any less of a skeeze-ball, but he did not force himself on her.

reply share

add reply

formatting help