MovieChat Forums > Batman: Year One (2011) Discussion > Punching a Dude Who Has Your Baby?

Punching a Dude Who Has Your Baby?


I suppose Gordon had no choice; If the guy would have gotten away, the baby was as good as dead in his eyes.

But punching a dude with your son in his arms!? I find it a bit odd that there seemed to be no hesitation at all. Just swinging away punch after punch. Only complaint of the movie.

It was great otherwise.

reply

Well he's a good trained cop, I suppose that's not the first time he faces a situation like this.
(of course first time with his own son...)

reply

Haha i totally agree. Even if he is a trained fighter.

reply

what about gordon not looking at the backseat with the guy with his baby? that was a huge complaint from me.

reply

that's a good 50:50 chance, rather than 100% chance of his son be killed.

reply

That is typical Frank Miller writing, in all of his comics you have at least one moment where a character does something that is puzzling

reply