MovieChat Forums > Thorne: Scaredycat (2010) Discussion > Sandra Oh was annoying (Spoilers)

Sandra Oh was annoying (Spoilers)


Did anyone find Sandra Oh annoying? First of all I would like to know how come she was a cokehead and yet working in such a position. I still don't understand how she couldn't realise that it was only Palmer in the room instead of thinking it was two people.

And why go alone to find a killer? Even if she wasn't afraid of Palmer, did she think she could scare off Knickles, a man who supposedly had killed so many people? When Palmer walked up to her, she just stood there and practically gave him the gun. What kind of detective is that. And she didn't even have her own gun. She got the one from the department's log stuff.

When he held the gun to her I was saying "shoot her" for her stupidity.

This show annoyed me. I loved Sleepyheads but this one didn't measure up. Glad they killed off Sandra's character so she doesn't have to come back with her cokehead habits.


This is my signature and I'm sticking to it. lol

reply

I cant stand Sandra Oh! The answer to all your questions is: She is a cokehead.

reply

I did't find her that irrational, but yes, she was very annoying.

reply

I'm having a hard time discerning if you're annoyed with Sandra Oh the actress, or the direction of her character. If it's the latter, then blame the director and writers.

reply

I guess I didn't make it clear enough. I don't think she would do those stupid things on her own, so I would have to blame the director and writers. But, couldn't they see how silly some of the things were? I can't understand it. I think my initial opinion has creditable concerns.




This is my signature and I'm sticking to it. lol

reply

Sorry if I wasnt clear. I was annoyed with the character, not the actress.


The ability to always see the worst in people and situations is often a hiding place for fear.

reply

Worst character ever. And what was all that eastern dramatic theme music when she appeared? This kind of music is mostly used before something unusually dramatic happens. I dont know maybe could be used on the scenes with the kid Charlie. Seeing her snorting coke with this music was so out of place. Her character was so unneccessary and out of place. She was okay at first but at one point it just went crazy. I almost felt like this character fell off to the show from some other story. It was just weird. I literally felt happy when she finally died.

I also think this was much worse than Sleepyhead. I guessed the killer on the first ten or twenty minutes. And found it very similar to Luther's last season, i suppose Luther was written later, but it was much better and it had fresh ideas. This one just went unneccesarily dramatic and lost its eccentricity every minute.

Sleepyhead was more interesting but even that wasn't handled sufficiently interesting. I think the show just needs some touches outside of miserable backstories.

Actually I think Luther is a successful version of this show. It is interesting, even though Thorne as a character is a good one Luther on Luther is even better and it's other characters are much more interesting, not to mention its legendary character Alice Morgan. And it manages to import interesting ideas to itself successfully with intriguing stories. Maybe this comparison shouldn't be made, and at some point i wasn't willing to do that but Thorne is much more similar to Luther than i thought, so i think this is fair.

reply


Yes Prequell, while I'm not sure about the Luther comparisons, I do like Luther. I haven't finished watching the series though. I found it online only a couple of months ago and I've since watched the first 2 seasons. I think I have another season to watch; haven't seen the last one as yet but I plan to. I think it's great and while I loved Sleepyheads, this Thorne one with Sandra Oh I found was terrible.


This is my signature and I'm sticking to it. lol

reply

I was cheering for her to get shot as well, which is quite unusual for me.

wasnt this whole storyline misogynistic? the sole cop woman is a temptress, a sex doll, a coke head, and irrational, the other woman is a motherly boss.
cliches all over, and so is the serial killer with the dual personality killing gay men.

reply

Her character was definitely a contender for Worst Cop Ever. Casting Sandra Oh in that role was a huge mistake. Her accent was just horrible. There are so many other actresses who could have done that so much better!

As for the character's behavior with Palmer, I think she went alone with the intention of killing him to prevent him from testifying about her behavior (she badgered him, left the door unlocked, sent the other cop off for coffee, nicked into the bathroom to snort coke, and then proceeded to start whaling on the guy in the back of the car). Had she been trying to redeem herself and her career by capturing him, she wouldn't have signed out a weapon from the evidence locker.Hhe did this after days of no sleep, lots of coke, a hell of a whack from the car wreck, and the panic of having been found out by Thorne, so it's pretty safe to say that chick was not in her right mind. My only problem with her death was the fact that it was blamed on Thorne. Yeah, I know he's the Tortured Hero (TM), but it was really heavy-handed.


Ali

reply

Thorne was the one that was messed up in this story. He let the murderer go after he turned himself in, just to prove his stupid and wrong theory that there were two murderers, and poor Sandra Oh and the hotel guy got blown away because of Thorne's stupidity.
No wonder she became a coke head.

reply

"Thorne was the one that was messed up in this story. He let the murderer go after he turned himself in, just to prove his stupid and wrong theory that there were two murderers, and poor Sandra Oh and the hotel guy got blown away because of Thorne's stupidity.
No wonder she became a coke head."


It was established that she was a coke user from the onset. Thorne didn't have anything to do with that.


Ali

reply

Yeah, but he got her killed because of his stupid hunches.
In fact, if you look at both stories, Phil more or less solved both cases.
I don't know how he's portrayed in the books, but in these two stories on ENC,
he seems a little too driven by these cases.

reply

The books have the same basic core stories but the characterisations on TV are totally different to the originals.
The one that annoyed me most is Phil who is written as a gay ,tattooed,multi pierced (one for each boyfriend) rebel who is excellent at t his job with a dry sense of humour who acts as a foil for the more serious Thorne. But I suppose that the actor cast as Phil has played the gay part so brilliantly in the past that he may not want to revisit it for this for fear of type casting.


Mal,they are starting to damage my calm!

reply

He said in Sleepyheads that he was a poof.

reply

I agree with all your points except for her acting - she's a good actress, but her character and lines were awful.

David Morrissey was awful - bad lines, bad acting, passable character. I mean, the guy was just cringe to watch.

The scene in the bathroom made no sense. She tries to get out of the apartment and couldn't - if she were trying to avoid alerting him, why return to the room? Oh yea, to get her jacket. WTF!

When she knew she was found out, why run to the bathroom where it'll be harder to escape. If anything, bust out through the front door.

I couldn't fault her acting because that was the script.

reply

Truly awful in every aspect; writing, and direction especially. I've never been happier to see a character dead than Sarah Oh's. The only thing that would have made me like this, is if Thorne was killed too.

reply

She was clearly made to be despicable so as to make her death less "tragic".

reply