The apple pie


When the step mom (before she's a step mom) leaves Nigel an apple pie he lifts a whole piece in the air. You couldn't do this with an American style apple pie. Is the English version different, a little more cake-like? It looks really good, I'd like to make one. Anyone have a fave recipe?
Thanks

reply

I'm no expert, but from the looks of that slice, it seems like she had a very tightly packed multi-layer of apple in there, and that possibly it had all cooled and congealed into a solid mass that kept it firmly together. That looked like a slice from a pie long-cooled, perhaps even from the fridge.

Apple pies in England are essentially not that different in recipe or result from American ones; I've not heard of a more cake-y one, no.

But I remember my mother's apple pies would -- if they lasted long enough to sit around in the fridge -- sort of congeal into something that looked as "firm" as that slice in the movie. His slice also looked massively thicker than anything I saw my mum make!



reply

Do you mean a thick apple pie like the one in this recipe? I just give you the link but maybe it's not what you're looking for?
Best,
http://www.simplyrecipes.com/recipes/extra_thick_apple_pie/

reply

It reminds of a Dutch Apple Pancake - look it up, they are amazing!

reply

It's more like the apple pie we have in Italy, where you put apples on top of the dough and once cooked the dough is soft and thick and fluffy.
Here's a link to a recipe (and pictures) if you want I can translate the recipe for you. :-)

http://www.misya.info/2007/07/05/torta-di-mele.htm

reply

It was a stunt pie.

reply

Exactly.

reply

I noticed that too myself about the Apple Pie being more firm than even my own would be after sitting in the fridge for a couple days. However, from what I noticed in this movie, even the Lemon meringue pie was HUGE. I wondered if it was just made to make the food actually become almost it's own character in the movie, larger than life as it were. I know I found my mouth watering at the food and that could have been what the filmmaker was going for. It could have just been to make the food really jump out at the audience.

reply

I noticed in this movie, even the Lemon meringue pie was HUGE. I wondered if it was just made to make the food actually become almost it's own character in the movie, larger than life as it were.


That's quite possible, that the food is dramatically over-sized in order to make a visual statement....though the character of Mrs. Potter is also supposed to be an extraordinary and inventive cook, with lots of technical baking secrets.

I can imagine her futzing with the recipe for years, and ending up with a special pie that's exactly as tall and firm as she wants : )


.

reply