MovieChat Forums > Mental (2013) Discussion > Issues with accents and humour

Issues with accents and humour


I was reading the reviews here and was surprised to find so much vexation regarding the accents in this film. They're pretty spot-on. I've been all over Australia, and plenty of people in Tassie do indeed speak just like Shaz. Lots of people have a more "received pronunciation" as in the character of Doris. There are variations in the Australian accent, not just regional but sort of "class" based as well (for lack of a better term). For instance, I speak differently to some people who hail from the same area as I do.

I think the issue here is that most people just plain aren't used to hearing it in the movies. And a lot of Australians, such as people who live in Melbourne, can be rather pretentious and don't want to risk giving the impression of having no sophistication, etc etc.

It was filmed around my local area in northern NSW, and part of the reason this film appealed to me so much was that it encapsulated so many aspects of the place perfectly. I think a fair bit of the humour might be lost on a foreign audience - for instance, the character of Trevor Blundell being a pisstake on Vic Hislop, the shark hunter, and the broadly accented Shaz triumphing over the wannabe-posh, well spoken, clean cut Australian middle class who often suffer from a lot of cultural cringe and look down on those who aren't so well spoken. Not to mention the unashamedly stereotypical character of "Trout" with the bleached hair, the job at the water park, the silly nickname, the love of surfing, etc - perfect pisstake on the denizens of the Gold Coast (the non-meth dealing ones, at least).

People unfamiliar with the region, such as foreigners and people from Melbourne, would be unfamiliar with these stereotypes, and might not see the humour in the way these characters were constructed. And I guess that is a criticism of the film, that the humour is a bit too localised.

reply

I think the issue here is that most people just plain aren't used to hearing it in the movies. And a lot of Australians, such as people who live in Melbourne, can be rather pretentious and don't want to risk giving the impression of having no sophistication


People unfamiliar with the region, such as foreigners and people from Melbourne, would be unfamiliar with these stereotypes, and might not see the humour in the way these characters were constructed. And I guess that is a criticism of the film, that the humour is a bit too localised.



Biggest load of crap ever written. What sort of twit supports their theory using a self invented stereotype to support an argument.
All you have demonstrated is a hatred of anything from Melbourne.
Here is another stereotype for you to mull over. Are you familiar with the word bogan? You should be. You come from 'Northern NSW'.


No cash here!! Here, no cash!!! Cash, no!!!! Robbo? No Cash!

reply

The OP has a point. If you want a perfect example of snooty Melbournians read the post in this discussion thread entitled "More Northern Australian, I Feel".

reply

Aye, the land of OZ has many accents - not everyone speaks like bloody Crocodile Dundee or Steve Irwin for God's sake. I've been Down Under and have had bezzie mates from OZ.

Hailing from Great Britain, I can attest there are well over 150 dialect variants in the UK; however, most think RP is the British Accent which is the accent we are taught to use in public vs. our home accent. Not all Brits speak like Harry Potter or the Queen.

Stereotyping anyone or criticising a person's accent is not fair to yourself or them.

reply

Hey you can't generalise, many of us are familiar with the Spice Girls, Snog Marry Avoid, Geordie Shore and have also had the misfortune of hearing something come out of David Beckham's mouth. We know not all people from the UK talk with a posh accent.

reply