MovieChat Forums > Terra Nova (2011) Discussion > Why do shows like this one fail so miser...

Why do shows like this one fail so miserably?


I started watching the first few episodes because I liked the premise and it was good at first but then it started going downhill fast for me. The acting was mediocre at best, though some of the actors stand out better than the others. I could not stand that teenage son, wow we enter a world with dinosaurs and what do the writers focus on first? The son's poorly written and not well thought out resent of his father. I know they were thinking of character development but man the argument with the dad and son was just painful for me to watch. The rest of the episode didn't do much and the following two sucked.
Than it giot me thinking, why do modern scifi series like this fail so bad? I mean yeah I wasn't expecting the x-files but really, it seems like the writers these days, especially in american scifi, can't do better than coming up with the basic premise. I mean, for example, another fox show, Fringe, was doing pretty well in the first few seasons but then they screwed up by (spoilers) eliminating one of the major characters from the timeline but keep him in the show anyway. It ruined the dynamics the show had going on just for a cheap trick to get more ratings. Same here with this show, I liked how they set up the future and the human settlement in the past (or alternate time period?). But they just write the characters in a way that is cringe-worthy, if not flat out terrible. When I started watching this show, I didn't want to focus on unimportant family issues or boring plot lines. Why can't the producers just do something that does not feel forced and flows naturally? if they had done that with this show, than maybe it probably would've lasted.

Passengers will refrain from killing my soul! ~Bus Driver Stu Benedict

reply

1.Poor Writing
2.Too Expensive to make, which leads to...
3.Trying To Appeal To Too Many Viewer Groups (kids, adult nerds, dino fans etc)
4.Again,Poor Writing

'What is an Oprah?'-Teal'c.

reply

1.Poor Writing
2.Too Expensive to make, which leads to...
3.Trying To Appeal To Too Many Viewer Groups (kids, adult nerds, dino fans etc)
4.Again,Poor Writing


Reminds me more of TFA than Terra Nova.

reply

OP, I was with you until you mentioned Fringe, which has not only not failed, but has also gotten much better with the seasons.

I agree with the second poster in regards to trying to appeal to too wide a base. For me, the main flaw with Terra Nova was the whole "family friendly" vibe. It would have really benefited from a darker, more adult overall tone.

reply

Okay, maybe it didn't fail after season 3, just felt like the show skipped a few seasons and suddenly there's this thing about the observers taking over the world and no mention of the alt universe and Peter being erased from the timeline never mentioned again... I just think the show could have done better had they not wasted time on the "episode of the week" format from the xfiles and went with the breaking bad format with little to no filler episodes.

Passengers will refrain from killing my soul! ~Bus Driver Stu Benedict

reply

Second season was supposed to have been more darker.

reply

Darvidd has it right.
The teen love story was uninteresting. Who else was there for them.
Dark secrets are getting old. So help me if anything ends like 'Lost' again I'm done with network TV. Unoriginal and uncreative ending.
This stuff and most stuff on syffy must not be written by sci-fi fans.

reply

The teen love story was uninteresting


I disagree on that as the romance was rather refreshing.

Unoriginal and uncreative ending.


Totally wrong.

reply

Darvidd has it right.
The teen love story was uninteresting. Who else was there for them.
Dark secrets are getting old. So help me if anything ends like 'Lost' again I'm done with network TV. Unoriginal and uncreative ending.
This stuff and most stuff on syffy must not be written by sci-fi fans.

reply

Dark secrets are getting old. So help me if anything ends like 'Lost' again I'm done with network TV. Unoriginal and uncreative ending.

I have to ask, are you one of those people who think they all died in the crash? It's just that when Lost ended I saw a lot of posts from angry people, ranting about being let down, repeating over and over that they understood it, but then 9 times out of 10 it turned out they thought everyone had died in the first episode's plane crash. That ultimate reveal would have been extremely dull and uncreative, the actual final reveal certainly wasn't unoriginal (even if you didn't like it).

reply

I have to admit that I never got the Lost series.

What was the deal with those psycho islanders anyway??

reply

The reason they fail is because they fall into familiar patterns.
1) An evil human tries to destroy what noble humans are trying to achieve (aka 1950s Lost in Space)
2) Shows become episodic rather than arc, so you really don't care about the story
3) Too much emphasis on the "human experience" and too little real sci-fi
4) Cute kids
5) The show suddenly jumps the shark when all the writers leave, you notice
6) All tease and no results, too many sci-fi shows sit there and tease you with a never-ending conflict that seems to go on and on and on. Its like watching Star Blazers.
7) Some shows should have never made it to TV in the first place. "Revolution", I'm looking your way...

reply

Cute kids? I wanted to scream at those annoying, unreal, crappy acting brats from the moment I saw them. I hope it was irony because in my opinion they were quite the opposite of cute. Actually they were what made me turn off the TV. Don't even get my started on the teenage romance. The acting of Landon Liboiron/Josh Shannon alone was enough to ruin the show though.

reply

I think the biggest reason this failed is that most audiences don't want a family-oriented show anymore.

For my latest movie reviews and news:http://www.hesaidshesaidreviewsite.com/

reply

Why do shows like this one fail so miserably?

Making the mistake of putting an idiot like brannon braga on the payroll.

reply

[deleted]