MovieChat Forums > The Christmas Bunny (2010) Discussion > The Problem with Christian Writers Who D...

The Problem with Christian Writers Who Direct


The problem with The Christmas Bunny, Kirk Cameron Saves Christmas, and so on, is Christians who are set out to make a Christian film get so dead set on the religious rhetoric that they don't know how to tell a story. The dialogue sounds contrived, and often unnecessary. Just because you are supposed to tell your kids to put on a jacket and wipe off their feet, that doesn't mean it should be said in the film every time. It becomes distracting. Why do we need to go into the details about the Dad's job offer? Couldn't it be left at "Hey, the offer still stands if you want to work for this guy" instead of getting into the laundry list of benefits and company statistics? It's because these movies have no depth and rely on filler dialogue in between moments where they can make references to the lord. The other thing is, Christian Writer-Directors will put in uncomfortable scenes, and treat them with so much time and realism that they forget they've made a family film and not an old testament torture scene. You want to say "HEY YEAH, WE GET IT. HER MOM IS A FLOOZY HEROIN ADDICT. NOW CAN YOU GET BACK TO THE BUNNY, MY KID THOUGHT THIS WAS ABOUT A BUNNY". The last problem I have is that if you ARE making a Christian film, label it a Christian film instead of tricking people into going to church on DVD. I understand that Christmas and Christians often go together, but any of the best Christmas films can teach you that you can allow the viewer to know the characters in the film are Christian, without having them constantly hint with "You think your guy up there is looking out for us?" "Thank the Lord" "oh yes, bless you"

reply

Thanks for the heads up.

I was looking for a bunch of holiday movies to get me in the mood. I like dogs but thought I'd add this rabbit one because you don't see bunnies often.

But you review let me know this was not a film I wanted to waste 2 hours of my life on.

I wanted bunnies, not Xian rhetoric and sermonizing. Plus I wanted some quality.

I'm watching a documentary on becoming Santa instead.

reply

It's a great movie for bunny lovers

"Have you seen or touched any monkey's?" Monty, Late Show with David Letterman

reply

HOLY-DAY movies that have anything to do with the actual thing about, you know Jesus Christ being born or Christianity? Oh how dreadful! How dare people ruin our Christmas with you know, Christianity!



"Life is like a box of Krispy Kreme donuts".

reply

Perhaps I didn't watch the same movie. I didn't notice that much Christian dialogue and themes. Sure this movie could have been written a tad better, but I still loved it a lot.
It was an interesting journey watching this girl that was traumatized learn to deal and found comfort in bunnies, and the friendship with the old bunny lady. What exactly was churchy about this film?

reply

I didn't think that the Christian dialogue was too bad in this movie either. 'Christmas Grace' is one which secular viewers should beware of.

reply

Funny, because as a Christian that is how I feel about many secular directors. They have their secular ideology view in everything. They don't know how to tell a story. This is a Christian film, and if you have an issue with it there are many mediocre secular films you can watch.



"Life is like a box of Krispy Kreme donuts".

reply

Secularists are better at hiding their bias but sometimes they are just as painful as Christians with the hamminess. Especially when they try to vilify Christians.

But Christians should strive to make better art.

reply

Well, I agree that Christians should make better art. But in the case of a movie like this, its entertainment. And its not meant to be mind blowing. Point is, that your average secular movie isn't either. Yet when something is non-Christian people are more forgiving , even if something is tasteless and dull. Somehow being "Christian" means that its under all this scrutiny and put under some kind of litmus test. This is a solid movie, IMO.


"Life is like a box of Krispy Kreme donuts".

reply

I think the whole film is pretty awful, Christian or not. Except for Florence Henderson's performance.
Having children that were non verbal, it was utterly painful to watch how they dealt with a non verbal child who obviously had suffered from emotional abuse by her bio mom.

reply

The only problem with the Christian theme I had with the movie was praying to find her... WHEN SHE LEFT VERY CLEAR TRACKS! Completely ruined the suspension of disbelief in the movie.

reply

My sentiments exactly!

reply