MovieChat Forums > Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions (2010) Discussion > I would have liked it better if Noir's V...

I would have liked it better if Noir's VO + NPH switched spots.


Who else grew up on Spider-Man TAS? Oh well, it was nice to have him as a Spider-Man anyway.

reply

Nah, I thought Barnes did a fine job as Noir Spidey. He was snarky and sarcastic without being overly angry.

Also, NPH's voice would be too high-pitched for a darker take on the character.

reply

[deleted]

I would have LOVED it if Christopher Barnes was the voice for Amazing Spider-man. The only actor I wasn't actually impressed with was Neil Patrick Harris. His lines were the least creative or enjoyable and I just think his voice was too high for the part of Spider-man. I would have liked to see Sean Marquette voice Noir (who was the voice of Spider-man in the Ultimate Spider-man game).

Also, on a separate note, I would have loved to see the Spectacular universe depicted in the video game form over the Ultimate universe.

...

reply

I actually thought that Christopher Barnes fits better in Noir. His voice goes very deep and brooding, and that is FAR more fitting than Sean Marquette's scratchy, almost squeaky voice.

reply

In my opinion Christopher Daniel Barns was far better as Spider-Man Noir than what he ever was in the 90's Spider-Man cartoon. In the 90's Spider-Man cartoon he wasn't that great. MARRRRRRRRRRYYYYYYYYYY JAAAAAAAAANEEEEEE!!!

But as Spider-Man Noir he was great

reply