I usually hate people who complain about this but..
I think it's funny how some of the people have VERY British accents and some of them have Italian ones.
"Unless Alpert's covered in bacon grease, I don't think Hugo can track anything."
I think it's funny how some of the people have VERY British accents and some of them have Italian ones.
"Unless Alpert's covered in bacon grease, I don't think Hugo can track anything."
I also hate it when people make a big deal of the accents. As far as I'm concerned, it's the least important part of a movie or TV production, most of the time. I do feel that it is important if it is part of the character's overall persona. For example, Poirot's Belgian French accent is a big part of his total character, and goes along with his other physical and personality traits. David Suchet says that he worked on it for months to get it just right. But for Zen I just don't see it making any difference to the overall experience of watching it.
In real life, you never really know exactly what kind of accent you are going to run into. I live in west Texas, and I hear people say it as way-est Tay-ex-is. But I also hear people say it as wast (rhymes with last) Taxes. We have people around here speaking with many different accents.
Maybe Zen grew up in England, we don't really know. Or maybe he had an English babysitter. Maybe one or both of his parents were English. Maybe his favorite TV show as a kid was English.
We're already being asked to suspend disbelief in that, even though this show is happening in Rome, nobody is speaking Italian. So the accent they're speaking that English with just doesn't make any difference to me. I just feel like it's a waste of time to care about it so much.
Maybe Zen grew up in England, we don't really know. Or maybe he had an English babysitter. Maybe one or both of his parents were English. Maybe his favorite TV show as a kid was English.
But for Zen I just don't see it making any difference to the overall experience of watching it.
I have no prob if a bunch of Brits play Italians, with Brit accents, but not with 2 real Italians playing with real Italian accents.
If he's raised elsewhere--fine, but most of the rest have Brit accents.
Carpe Noctem!
Actually, I thought Zen's inflections and manner of speaking, as well as his looks and body language, made him easily convincing as Italian.
share[deleted]
As an American watching this show, I came on these boards to figure out what what on earth was going on with the accents. I thought there was something I missed. I agree with another poster, that having a few actors with Italian accents makes it exponentially more confusing.
Not sure if this is a regular occurrence with BBC shows, but it seems like they could do something to make it more clear to the audience that the British accents are to be ignored.