MovieChat Forums > 1 Girl 5 Gays (2009) Discussion > Favorites and least favorites

Favorites and least favorites



I love this show. I'm in the U.S. and I watch it on Logo at midnight. My least favorite guy on the show is David. He's too hyper and I do believe he thinks he's very attractive. I disagree.

I don't care for Ian Lynch either for the same reasons I don't like David. And don't forget the time he passed around a naked photo of himself. Who does that?

My two favorites are Dean and Jonathan, the one with the blond hair.

________________
I *heart* Brian Kinney- Biggest whore in Pittsburgh

reply

I really like the show. I watch it from the U.S. as well.


My favorites are Jake, Gerry, Johnathan Nathaniel and David. Jake, because he seems very genuine and down-to-earth (and he's bi-racial, which I thought was cool). Gerry, because throughout the segments he's been on, he hasn't realized that everyone is mellow and he can't seem to tone it down (and he's cute). I like Johnathan Nathaniel because he seems really sweet and kind. I like David because of the stories/perspectives he has on things, and he reminds me a lot of guys I knew in high school.

The members that I dislike are Dean, Juan, Yerxa (Michael) and Matt. I don't like Dean because he has a tendency to control the opinions, there always seems to be a hierarchy of persuasion when Dean is around, there's nothing wrong with having a strong opinion but it's probably that there aren't really any members whose opinions are as polar opposite to his (and not expressed forthright like his opinions are) it can cause the conversation to lean. With Yerxa it's more forced; like he said in one episode, "your OPINION can be wrong." That pretty much sums up why I don't like him.

With Matt, I just dislike his personality. Matt is immature and he's still at that selfish, boyish stage. Juan, is a bit of a biotch and a drama-queen rolled into one.

I like the entire cast it's just some I don't entirely agree with.

reply

[deleted]

I dislike Dean and Yerxa for the same reasons. They give off such an elitist attitude. They really seem think that their opinion has greater value over others for whatever reason. I agree about the Dean effect as well, they treat him like he's some saviour...bro is not that great and he's very smug. The panel is just a chance for them to be the "popular" people they never got to be in high school, its pathetic.

-----------------
HAHAHAH Your Funni.....


reply

I'm from Canada and my favourites are Juan black Jonathon and blonde Jonathon.

Can't stand Matt Barker but i think its because he's so naive.

http://26.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lcgw2fG1sC1qc382yo1_500.gif


reply

I'll just say my favourites: Jake, Yerxa, and Ian Lynch.

I live in Toronto where MTV Canada and 1 Girl 5 Gays is filmed, and I'm surprised I haven't met anyone from the show in person yet. I go to university and it's downtown, so I'm hoping to see one of my favourites in person...On a related note, I recently checked Matt Barker's Facebook and we know some of the same people.

ThePrisoner,Buffy,LOST&Alias!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZRRj7CVw-A

reply

I love this show too, it's hilarious and SO entertaining.
My favourites definatly have to be philip, blonde jonathan, JP, juan, and david!

reply

Let me set a list. lol
Least Favs.
JP- He really creeps me out sometimes, he's so awkward. I'm always imagining him saying the meanest things in his head. It was funny when he was named "Women's journal" or Reader's Digest or some lame magazine lmao
Yerxa- He's so elitist. I hate the way he talks down to Andrew and Matt Barker >.> His opinion is not the almighty dollar.
Dean- Smug.
David- ugh he is so extra! He always seems like he's trying to impress everyone on the panel with all his stories and blah blah talking. But everyone seems to eat it up, and the attention seeker he is, loves it so much. Also I hate his hairline, its disturbing.

Favorites.
Juan- I love Juan, he's so cute and funny. I love that he can state his opinion without talking down to others.
ummm thats about it for the favorites lol.

I like Matt Barker, but I wouldnt say he was my favorite. I think its so easy for everyone to look down on him and write him off, but I kinda feel bad for him. I'd like to hear more of him without everyone cutting him off all the time. Oh and Andrew is funny lmao, he can be a little bitchy, but I think he gets a bad rep with the whole phil situation. Of course everyone is gonna feel sorry for phil because he's fat, I think it just gets blown out of proportion.
-----------------
HAHAHAH Your Funni.....


reply

[deleted]

This is based on a very few viewings of episodes, but so far my favs are:
David and Santos and another guy who I can't remember, I think his name is Jake.
Least favorite, Juan and the black Jonathan

Lois Lane=Leia Lane

reply

Juan is my all time favorite, i start to laugh everytime he says something, I also like david.
The one person i really hate to listen to is Santos i just find him annoying

reply

I adore Santos(because he just says how he feels he doesn't give a ****) and JP because i think he's adorable. I love the show I watch it on LOGO almost every night after chelsea lately. and i really like the girl who's name i will not even attempt to spell.

I don't dislike anyone on the show though.

"Only love and music are forever" - Phantom of the Opera

reply

I officially can't stand Michael Yerxa! I think if I saw him on the street I would just have to slap him, and if Dean tried to run over and help, though I like him, I would have to snap his scrawny butt.

Lois Lane=Leia Lane

reply

I agree. I have grown to dislike Yerxa immensely. He's said some things I disagree with, which would be fine if he wasn't so stubborn about his own opinions.

reply

I like Matt Simms(only saw him once, wore a hat and kind of looked like Justin from Queer as Folk), he was very sweet and seemed very mature for his age. Also, like Santos, he seems very down to earth. He made me cry when he talked about being drugged and raped. Very sad. I like Matt Barker, but he is very immature and I don't like that he actually lets his boyfriend hit him and get away with it.

Other Likes: David, Jake, both Jonathans, Gerry and Andrew. Also, like Juan, I think he is sweet although he did show up to the one taping drunk.

Don't really have any dislikes, but I cannot stand the way Yerxa talks to the rest of them especially Matt Barker. He is always calling him a liar. I don't think anyone knows him well enough to make that determination. He also seems to be older than the rest of the panelists, so it seems he thinks he knows it all.

I am a straight female, but I love hearing all the comments. Most of them are very educational and even though I have several gay friends, I don't understand much about the culture. Bravo to this show for helping me with the culture side of things.

reply

FAVORITES:
- David
- Jake
- Ian
- Yerxa

LIKE:
- Gerry
- Jonathan (black one)
- Juan

DISLIKE:
- Andrew
- Matt Barker

Everybody is whatever.


reply

My Faves:
David- I noticed a few people here don't like him but I think he's one of the realest ones. He's so funny and he seems like a really nice person. And I love when he says peace lol.

Juan- Juan is probably the funniest on the whole show. I just love love love him.

Jonathan Nathaniel- I can tell that he really is a genuine person. He is the type of person I would want to be friends with. He's never a hater and doesn't spread negativity like some of the other ones. I think he's my favorite on the whole show.

Jonathan(blonde)- he's hilarious like Juan and his facial expressions are priceless.

Jake- He's one of the hottest guys on the show and he seems really cool.

Ian- I watched his comedy and he's pretty funny

Alex- Everything he says is so hilarious. And I love his beard. he reminds me of a gay thinner Zach Galifinakis

Ones that annoy me sometimes

Matt- I like him but he has some issues. I don't think he is a liar like they say he is but I think maybe he acts kind of immature about serious issues

Dean- I like him most of the time but sometimes he just doesn't make sense

Yerxa- thinks he know everything

also the one that said Phillip should be on Biggest Loser. That was a foul ass comment. I think it was Andrew.

JP-kind of annoys me in the way Dean does, but I still like him

Ones that amuse me but I don't see much

Santos-his nasally voice and crazy stories kill me

Thomas- The times that I have seen him he makes me laugh and I like his style

Philip- Seems like a real genuine person.

Simon- he's cute and I like him on the episodes I did see him on

Ish- He seems like he's been through a lot and I like the reasons he said he does the show.
I don't know who you think you are but before the night is through, I wanna do bad things with you

reply

Here's a new video Jake made for Ish: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQlDRoR1420

ThePrisoner,Buffy,LOST&Alias!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZRRj7CVw-A

reply

i try to watch this show as much as possible but sometimes i cant cuz it comes on so late anyway my faves are. andrew, matt, jp, jake, juan, and ish

reply

The only one I can't stand is Santos. He just grosses me out... No sense of propriety!

My favorites would have to be Yerxa, Ian, Matt, David, Andrew and blonde Jonathon.

reply

love ian even more Western and a Soph <3 amazing

reply

I like

Jake
Johnathan [black]
Juan
Philip

Dislike

Santos

Others I am pretty neutral about. I kind of just watched a bunch of episodes today, otherwise I would have not known their names. [boredom]


why...why?

reply