A fantasy ending.....


I am British, but don't live there any more. I hate the aristocracy and anything that related to them. There ought to be an alternative ending to Downton Abbey that supposedly took place in WWII. A squadron of German storm-troopers should invade the estate, assemble the cast and gun them all down in cold blood. There should be no survivors, just a river of blood. Sorry fan, but that is how I feel. Death to these make-believe period piece. We hates them, Precious!

reply

I've had thoughts along those lines. Only I would have it so that at least the servants were gone.

It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it- Aristotle

reply

Well, thankfully most of us aren't as bitter or nasty as you are.

If you feel this way, the sensible thing is to just not watch the programme.

reply

Then why did you watch the show if you don't like the aristocracy?

If it's all the same to you, I'll have that drink now.-Loki (Marvel's Avengers)

reply

Then why did you watch the show if you don't like the aristocracy?


Good question! "I hate the basic premise of the show and it should have been totally different." Well then that would have just been a different show. This isn't the only show that exists.

-
Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that I'll be over here looking through your stuff.

reply

[deleted]

Then why did you watch the show if you don't like the aristocracy?


I hate the aristocracy as well, but I really liked the show. The servants were my favourite part. But I liked the Crawleys too. I just saw it as a fun drama. I don't let my politics dictate everything.

reply

Sounds like a Socialist.

reply

I would disagree there. To me it sounds like a would-be Socialist who only thinks that killing something is the answer to whatever problem he has. It doesn't really matter what/who is killed as long as the ones being killed have something he doesn't.

_____________
I am the Queen of Snark, "I Shine, Not Burn".

reply

Just finished watching the marathon on our local PBS, and I loved the finale. Many of us watched it for the fantasy. It took us out of grim reality for awhile.

I could be a morning person if morning happened at noon.

reply

[deleted]

Lol!

Whatever happened to that one British socialist commenter who frequently wished the Crawleys and Downton would burn? Jan something.

reply

I suspect Americans love the fantasy of aristocracy, but in reality won't tolerate it. The closest we came to having aristocracy were the southern plantation owner. One of our beloved military leader, Gen Sherman under our greatest president, Lincoln reduced a huge part of the south to charred cinders.

reply

One of our beloved military leader, Gen Sherman


While he may have been respected as a strategist, Sherman was scarcely "beloved," especially among the survivors of his scorched-earth assault on the civilians in his path.

reply

America is just as much a class-driven society as any other. The haves and have nots, the celebrity and the non celebrity, the rich and the not rich. While we do not have an aristocracy quite like that depicted in Downton Abbey, it is still very much present. Americans worship movie stars, reality stars, pop singers, etc just as much as the British used to put the aristocracy on a pedestal.

DA was just a high class soap opera. The finale could have easily been written for Dynasty or Knots Landings. Pure fantasy. If you go into it not expecting anything more than that, it is quite enjoyable.

reply