MovieChat Forums > Le moine (2011) Discussion > The character of Ambrosio (spoilers for ...

The character of Ambrosio (spoilers for film and book)


The book is a long Gothic novel that contains a deep and searing criticism of those in religious orders and, implictly, the way in which certain sections of society find themselves pressed into a religious order some times against their will.

Ambrosio of the book is much more evil than the film character. It's quite clear in the book that his rearing by the monks has accentuated the worst aspects of his personality and left him unprepared for any weaknesses or deficits he might have. Consequently he lacks compassion for others' deficits and weaknesses. The book Ambrosio exploits people and treats them as objects in the satisfaction of his desires. The film's Ambrosio was a more sympathetic character and his struggle and inner turmoil had a poignancy to it lacking in the book. Not that Ambrosio doesn't regret things or think otherwise about his actions in the book, but not enough to stop his acceleration to hell.

I'm not trying to break your heart,
I'm just trying hard not to fall apart

reply

Thank you. After reading 'The Castle of Otranto' and 'Vathek' at seventeen, I wanted to read 'The Monk' as well but could not find it. Probably now, with the internet, it's a lot easier.

But when I found this film, "Le Moine' with Vincent Cassel, I was curious and watched it. I think it's a wonderful film, maybe not faithful to the novel as Ambrosio is concerned, but still a fascinating story, well told, well acted.




"I don't discriminate between entertainment
and arthouse. A film is a goddam film."

reply

Hello. I've just checked Amazon for the UK, Canada and USA and all have The Monk. So if Amazon sites are stocking it then I'm sure you'll be able to get it to read now. I found The Monk slightly different to other gothic novels I read when younger in that the supernatural and hysterical elements are less. The novel is really focused on evil and its origins and how it manifests amongst monks and nuns. It's an interesting read especially the later parts of the book that describe Ambrosio's psychology. Astounding that such a novel was written by such a young man. I think Lewis was 19 when he wrote it.

Although both differ I really like film and book. I thought Cassel was great as Ambrosio. I felt his tale in the film was sadder than in the book.

Why do you refuse to remember me?

reply