MovieChat Forums > Amour (2012) Discussion > I didn't know who would die first...

I didn't know who would die first...


...the woman, or me from the excruciating boredom.
This movie shouldn't be called Amour, it should be called Spend Two Hours Watching An Old Woman Die While Every Now And Then Her Husband Tells A Pointless Story Or Spends 5 Minutes Chasing A Pigeon Around The House.

I know, I know, I should go watch Iron Man 3, or something less profound and deep. Let me tell you a little secret: There is nothing profound or deep about this movie. Keep trying to convince yourself otherwise, if that's what makes you feel artsy and refined.
Yeah, dying sucks. We've all seen it, probably, with one of our loved ones. However, just showing that for two hours does not a good movie make. Doing your taxes also sucks, and it's something people have to do in real life, yet I'm not about to go prop up a camera in my living room while I sit down and work out my W-2 and expect people to consider that a movie.

I will say this, the scene where he smothers her almost made the 2 hour long dreck worth it.

reply

Can't agree with you more!

reply

There is nothing profound or deep about this movie.


Well really the film I think then is too 'early' for you. Either that or perhaps you are not using your imagination hard enough. And out of respect I won't bring up the other reason.

reply

Same, I saw it at the cinema, but I don't believe I would have the patience to watch it at home. Felt empty and uninvolving, than again I haven't seen a Haneke film I truly enjoyed, he's certainly no Bergman.

reply

bump

reply

You hate the movie but yet you stick around to bump your topic over a year after you created it?

At least it's a memorable movie then!

reply

I know I'm coming late to the party but I watched it today. I kind of agree with you. But I liked the movie. I just thought that some scenes were unecessarily long. For example, right at the start, they're part of an audience (watching a concert/orchestra, I believe). And the camera just films the audience for a very long time. At first I thought ok, I like this, it's interesting. It's new (at least for me). It allows you to observe every member of the audience. I get the point. But it's still too long, it gets boring. Same thing when he gets the scissors and starts cutting the flowers from the stems. I actually started to get anxious and thought "do we have to watch him do this to every single one?". Some of the scenes dragged on for too long, and instead of telling us something it was just boring. JMO, of course.

And on some small level, I think you owe me something for deceiving me so exquisitely.

reply

I love the title you're suggesting. It would've prevented me from watching this unsufferable thing so-called movie

reply

I found it quite boring as well

reply

Agreed. There was nothing new here. If you've ever seen someone decline & die IRL, you've seen this movie.

reply