MovieChat Forums > Old 37 (2015) Discussion > Directed By Alan Smithee means Movie is ...

Directed By Alan Smithee means Movie is likely to be awful


For anyone who doesn't know who Alan Smithee is.

The Directors Guild contract generally does not permit a director to remove her/his name from films. The Directors Guild has been striving for decades to establish the director as the "author" of a film, and part of getting the credit for the successes is taking the blame for the failures. The only exceptions they make are cases in which a film was clearly taken away from a director and recut heavily against her/his wishes in ways that completely altered the film. Directors are required to appeal to the Guild in such cases. If the appeal is successful, their name is replaced by Alan Smithee. So if you notice a film directed by Alan Smithee, it is certain it is not what its director intended, and likely that it is not any good.

Smithee has a long resume, they made a movie about him as well.

But it means beware of this film. Although I have seen one Smithee film I enjoyed.

Anyway I post this for those who might not know.
All the best

reply