MovieChat Forums > Phil Ochs: There But for Fortune (2011) Discussion > Best documentary nomination for 2011 ?

Best documentary nomination for 2011 ?


This movie was a stunning and stirring tribute to two things: The beloved (but far-too-neglected) musician, Phil Ochs, and the oft-tributed 1960's. Weaving the topical songwriter's biography through the fascinating history of his time helps make sense of the indelible stamp that decade left on our souls. Appropriately, it doesn't end well, but does capture that "we can change the world" empowerment that may presently and forever be rekindled. Here you will find beautiful music (but seldom the whole song) and filmed insights into the early Greenwich Village folk scene, the riots at the 1968 Democratic Convention, the assassination of the Kennedy's, and as Phil embraced the world-at-large, the CIA-backed coup that helped install South American dictator, Pinochet. Here is understanding for that phrase, "the personal is political and the political is personal." The real power-punch is that for those who know his songs.. The themes are still relevant after 40+ years ! Sample these lyrics (I believe from 1965), "We own half the world, Oh Say Can You See. And the name for our profits is democracy. So like it or not you will have to be free. Cause we're the cops of the world." Well, one update is necessary.. Because of those policies we no longer own half the world. If only Phil were with us now I have no doubt he would have similarly and poetically explained the financial collapse, the tea party, Citizens United, Iraq and Afghanistan, and the Wisconsin attack on unions. His gift filtered out complexities through a sharp lens of social justice and distilled the truth into a tune you could hum. Nobody did it better.

reply

I enjoyed it but in order for it to win awards it would need the same creativity that Phil put into his songs. The poster was brilliant and I expected something more poetic and lyrical but instead it was pretty conservative and felt, well, "documentary." I still plan on buying and watching it again.

reply

When was it released? IMDb says 2010 and Rotten Tomatoes says 2011. Just wondering if it will qualify for the 2012 Oscars. Wikipedia says the release date was January 2011.

reply

It first screened at the Woodstock Film Festival in October 2010, but was released to the public January 5, 2011.

reply

It ran for one week in LA in 2010 in order to qualify for the academy awards. It did not receive a nomination and is ineligible for 2011.

reply

It is a brilliant documentary about a man with many external demons and even more internal ones. On the other hand, in many respects it is as bleak and inaccessible as the man it portrays, so I'm not surprised it had a very limited audience and received no nominations. That's OK, because those who know Phil's music have sought out this superb portrait of an extremely troubled soul. 9/10 stars from me.

reply