MovieChat Forums > The Woman in Black (2012) Discussion > Who found out that there were papers

Who found out that there were papers


At the woman in blacks house? And why not do it themselves/why as Daniel to travel just to see em? They can't find anyone else?

reply

The solicitor who owned the law firm knew the papers were there, because he'd gone there when Alice was alive and had been handling her legal affairs. He didn't want to go himself because, well, EEL MARSH HOUSE and WOMAN IN BLACK! He sent Arthur because he was also a solicitor, but an underling. Someone from the firm had to go, who was also a solicitor, not just a clerk.

reply

Yup. Except he didn't go (IMO) because it was a tedious, hateful job to have to go and do, so it went to the guy at the bottom of the barrel. Arthur.

"The Martian Manhunter is the heart of the Justice League." - The Flash (Barry Allen)

reply

I think we're saying the same thing :)

reply

Yeah, I think I just mistook what you said when you mentioned the woman in black. I realize now you were joking, but first when I read it I was like "He couldn't have known about that." 😃

"The Martian Manhunter is the heart of the Justice League." - The Flash (Barry Allen)

reply

I think he did know about the Woman in Black from his previous visit there. Other than that, yes, we're saying the same thing :)

reply

Ah, well I disagree with you there, I think it was pure laziness/pass it down the ladder. But it's open to interpretation ☺

"The Martian Manhunter is the heart of the Justice League." - The Flash (Barry Allen)

reply

Arthur's boss at the law firm had been to Eel Marsh House when Alice was alive, and wasn't keen on making the trip again. Whether he knew about the Woman in Black is debatable, but he presumably knew about the various deaths that had taken place at the house, and was visibly shaken when he mentioned Nathaniel's death. So he would have been keen to delegate.

He said that Jerome (the local solicitor in Crythin Gifford) was handling Alice's affairs on their behalf, but "he's not really been cooperating" (for obvious reasons). So they had to send one of their own out there to get the job done. Of course, travelling across the country to sort through some reclusive widow's dusty old paperwork in her tumbledown nightmare mansion was hardly a job for the up-and-comers at the firm, but a perfect opportunity for Arthur (the guy who wasn't pulling his weight) to redeem himself by doing the dirty job no one else wanted to do.

So basically the crap rolled downhill, and Arthur was at the bottom.

reply