MovieChat Forums > Am Anfang war das Licht (2013) Discussion > This Movie is Now Responsible for At Lea...

This Movie is Now Responsible for At Least One Death


The phrase "Too goddamn stupid to live" comes immediately to mind. Did this moron seriously think people could do this and live???

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/more-news/swiss-woman-starved-to-deat h-on-daylight-diet/story-e6frf7lf-1226339082591?sv=90aca59a96b36b808b3 a32a4915440

A Swiss woman starved to death after believing she could survive on light alone.

The woman embarked on the diet after watching the controversial 2010 documentary film "In the beginning there was light," newspaper Tages Anzeiger said today.

The movie centres on Swiss chemistry doctor Michael Werner, 62, and 83-year-old Indian yogi Prahlad Jani, who both claim to derive sustenance from spiritual means rather than the intake of food - a concept also known as breatharianism.

Werner claims to have lived without food since 2001, while Jani told the documentary of how he had lived for 70 years not only without food, but also without water.

The woman, from the east of Switzerland, saw the movie and decided to try to survive entirely on light, preparing for the process by reading a book by Australian breatharian Ellen Greve, who goes by the name Jasmuheen.

In line with the book, the Swiss woman, who was in her early 50s, did not eat or drink anything for a week - and even spat out her saliva - before resuming drinking in the second and third weeks.

She reassured her concerned children that she would stop fasting if it became dangerous but she was found dead by them at her home last winter.

An autopsy showed that she died of starvation, ruling out any other contribution to the cause of death, the newspaper reported.

This was the fourth known death linked to breatharianism and Jasmuheen's books since the practice emerged in the early 90s.

reply

The only moron here is YOU(RaiderDuck), for not understanding the process of breatharianism. Please do everybody a favour and enlighten yourself FIRST about a subject BEFORE delivering comment.

Did you know that there are already at least 15,000 successful(still living) breatharians around the world? The fact that somebody has died watching this movie is not the fault of the movie. It is the same as saying that because of a movie about "Driving Cars" one person has died in a car accident! That doesn't make it the movie's fault. What about the other 10,000,000 successful drivers?

reply

Then how come not one of these breatharians has ever proven it? They've been tested time and time again, and it's always the same story: they're either hiding food someplace or sneaking out to an all-night Burger King at 3am.

And what, pray tell, is the scientific mechanism by which air and light are converted by the human body into water, amino acids and carbohydrates? How does this happen? What mechanism does the human body use? Until you can answer these questions sensibly, please refrain from name-calling.

reply

As to the first part of your question, who are you talking about? Name the people that you say have been tested and who have failed.

As to the second question, that is exactly my point, you have no idea how this mechanism works, but you want to comment on it.

Who is doing name-calling? The following was your sentence, and I quote -
"Did this moron seriously think people could do this and live???"

I didn't say that, you did.

Please study your subject before making false comments about it.
You affect a lot of people with your false, negative comments.
This phenomenon has been known for hundreds, even thousands of years.
It is also called Inedia, Breatharianism, Waterianism, etc. Please look it up in the dictionary.

reply

Fact: There is no known scientific mechanism by which the human body could convert sun and wind into carbohydrates and protein.

Fact: Every Breatharian ever subjected to a controlled environment and testing is either caught sneaking food or begins to exhibit signs of starvation before the test is ended.

Fact: No intelligent person believes that a human could survive without food or water.

But some people aren't happy with the real world and prefer woo-woo nonsense instead.

Whatever.

reply

Please prove your facts, before we can trust your "facts"...

reply

[deleted]