MovieChat Forums > The X Factor (2011) Discussion > Previous winners ..

Previous winners ..

posted 10 years ago by wildfire160
5 replies | jump to latest

Were any of the Previous winners on the show as guests??
ive been watching but dont think any of them were on.
"Nee ta ma duh tyen-shia suo-yo duh run doh gai si"

[–] I_Guard_Tanelorn 10 years ago

I think its a Running Man situation with the winners.

[–] scissorhands__emily 10 years ago

Have they even mentioned Tate Stevens this season? He seems like a colossal fail. Has he done anything? Did he release his CD?

[–] kade5233 10 years ago

He released a not very successful album. Melanie Amaro is yet to release anything.

[–] scissorhands__emily 10 years ago

I looked on iTunes and nothing from Tate was on there. There is stuff for Melanie, although it just looked like 3 singles (not very impressive).

[–] principesse 10 years ago

Melanie Amaro performed last year and it was forgettable. I think this is the main weakness of the show, actually. Every year, it needs to be able to get last year's winner to perform at the finale and they need to be recognizable. This year, it seemed like they were ashamed of Tate and Melanie's lack if success, so didn't want to acknowledge them at all.