MovieChat Forums > Waiting for 'Superman' (2010) Discussion > Learned helplessness: 'Nobody's coming t...

Learned helplessness: 'Nobody's coming to save us'


In the first five minutes of this propaganda film, a man talks about how he cried when his mother told him that Superman doesn't exist. He says he cried because it was then he realized that "nobody was coming to save us."

With that one line he has illuminated the biggest problem many poor people of all racial backgrounds suffer from: that of learned helplessness; of depending on the benevolent government to "save" them from themselves.

If you've been alive longer than 20 years, you have learned by now that the government isn't here to help people, but to disarm them and render them helpless, to render them unable to help themselves, and are therefore easier to control, both at the voting poll and in life in general.

Do a google search for "Americans Suffer From Learned Helplessness".

This movie is disturbing, because so many people are unaware that many "documentary" films like this one are really nothing more than neoliberal propaganda.




reply

Your last line is interesting.
Other posters on this board have criticised this film as being right-wing/conservative propaganda.
I thought that was unusual since this is the same director as brought us 'An Inconvenient Truth"
As for your main comment about the learned helplessness, I think the guy you are talking about, Mr Canada (he didn't even have to compete to win that title), must have gotten over that mindset because he went out and became part of the solution.
Good for him.

"They who... give up... liberty to obtain... safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."

reply

I think the OP called the propaganda "neoliberal," not right-wing. Neo-liberal tends to mean socially left wing but economically pro-corporate or anti-labor. Regardless of which side of the political spectrum it lies, propaganda it is.

Here's a list of propaganda techniques; most can be found in Waiting For Superman:

http://www.dailywritingtips.com/50-types-of-propaganda/

Because you're an idiot. No, no, don't look like that, practically everyone is.~Sherlock

reply