No Justice in Hollywood


I know no will agree with me but I think both For Greater Glory and Andy Garcia showed have got nominated for oscar awards

reply

I agree. But alas, Hollywood really only nominates from a select pool of favorites. It's less an "awards" show and more just a pre-scripted pat on the back. And this isn't because my favorites don't usually get the recognition and more because you can pretty much guess the winners before half the movies even come out.

__
Writing is my favorite hobby. Writing something that many can enjoy is my favorite dream.

reply

I know no will agree with me but I think both For Greater Glory and Andy Garcia should have got nominated for Oscar awards


They should have, but left-wing Hollywood wouldn't do it to save their souls.

http://booklocker.com/books/6520.html

reply

You are correct!

reply

It is not so much left or right. It is a matter of understand that Catholic religion has always been a danger to various interests that I won't name here but people are growing aware of them. The same interests today that control Hollywood and by this it would include the distribution of movies are the ones that the Cristeros fought against. A movie of this level, with such a cast of actors should have every right to be distributed in main countries in Europe (UK, France, Germany).

reply

The story is known by very few in America I can only imagine it is probably known by even fewer in Europe.
I know Americans like to think our film industry is the biggest and best but Europe has it's own industry. I don't think the fact that it didn't get distributed in Europe has anything to do with a "Liberal Hollywood". It's just business. European distributors probably saw more profit in a domestic film.
The cast isn't that good. Sure Andy Garcia is a star and Peter O'Toole has a glorified cameo but the rest are just good character actors (although it appears that Oscar Isaac is on the cusp of stardom now.)
I know IMDb message boards aren't the place to look for objectivity, but try to put your personal religious and political beliefs aside and see this movie is just an ok propaganda film.

reply

You are perfectly right. This movie deserved several nominations - for Andy Garcia, for the director, for music, cinematography and costumes... I've seen most of the nomnated movies this year and I really don't understand why this movie was so snubbed. Or maybe I do...?

reply

The boy who played Jose should've also gotten a supporting nod.

__
Writing is my favorite hobby. Writing something that many can enjoy is my favorite dream.

reply

This movie offends various interests - the extreme Stalin-era left, atheist godless liberals, Catholic hating mason Christians, and Jews who believe they were the only minority ever persecuted for religious reasons. It just wouldn't do to promote any Hollywood movie that takes anything but a cynical, mocking, derisive portrayal of Catholicism.

reply

This was a very poor movie. Simple as that. It didn't deserve any sort of accolades.

reply

It had nothing to do with "left-leaning Hollywood". The film was a very limited summer release and it still bombed (although it was a hit in Mexico).
In spite of a incredible cast and story the film unfortunately fell into a predictable formula and was rather cliche.
Had it been nominated it would have gone up again Lincoln, Zero Dark Thirty, and (winner) Argo.
I know Conservative Catholic foam at the mouth over this movie but any objective viewer will tell you it's just an ok picture.

reply

I haven't seen the film but I would appreciate a comment from someone who has seen both this film and THE FUGITIVE (1947 version). This film with Henry Fonda and directed by John Ford seems to have covered the same period and conflict between an atheist state and organized religion.

reply