MovieChat Forums > Dolphin Tale (2011) Discussion > 25% of you give this a 10 rating????

25% of you give this a 10 rating????


Are you people serious about giving this movie a 10? A 10 is for the upper elite of all films of all time. Somewhere you "10" voters equate this movie with the likes of oh I don't know .. Godfather, Citizen Kane, Casablanca, etc. This is worse than Pee Wee's Great Adventure! Wise up!

reply

[deleted]

What you feel is a good movie, and what other's feel is a good movie are two different things. Personally, I would rate the Godfather <4... and this I will give a 10 because of the message, and the way it makes you feel. Just because someone says something is "the best", doesn't mean its close to being it.

Disclaimer: The previous statements may be considered offensive.

reply

Absolutely right. I gave it 10, and i don't care what is suppose to be big movies blockbusters, i have my own taste and im not ashame of that.

I personally think that many of "BIG" movies are just crap, but i don't own Hollywood and i don't have money to spread my ideas, so im in minority and it doesn't matter what i say to millions of those who think that godfather, avatar batman and similar movies are suppose to have best rating.

This is great movie with great massage with avoided many clichés with epic music, fast editing, killing thousands of people, perfect costumes...

=================
I saw this film for free... and still wanted my money back.

reply

In my opinion this film is better than Citizen Kane. Seriously. Citizen Kane gets kudos because it's credited with technical innovations that were influential (even if it wasn't really the source of many of those) and because it became an entrenched sacred cow.

Try thinking for yourself instead.


http://www.rateyourmusic.com/~JrnlofEddieDeezenStudies

reply

I would never give this a 10
Free Willy I gave I think an 9 out of 10
But still Dolphin Tale was an all right film I thought it might be sad but there were not really any sad bits so I gave it a 6 out of 10.



www.youtube.com/eastangliauk

reply

I've never seen any of the movies the OP mentioned, though I know they're classics of the film industry. With the latter two, I just haven't gotten around to it, but I've absolutely zero interest in the "Godfather" series. Just no.

As to "Dolphin Tale," honestly I don't know how anyone with a soul could hate this movie, or its sequel. You may need to see your dentist after, but the sweetness is justified. It showcases the best reasons for living- family, friendship, love, and helping others. In our often too-cynical world, I'd say that's a message worth listening to.

Plus, they're my two year old daughter's favorite movies. :-D You wouldn't believe the excitement.

reply