MovieChat Forums > Essential Killing (2010) Discussion > Not very original - Seraphim Falls goes ...

Not very original - Seraphim Falls goes Eurasia


Don't know if this is supposed to be a ground breaking film, but me feeling is that is a shameless blueprint of the movie Seraphim Falls http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0479537/ , except Essential killing has not really got a dialogue or plot. Could easily have been the same director of photo.

reply

No, if it were a "shameless blueprint" of Seraphim Falls then that would mean Essential Killing had preceded and influenced it, not the other way around. If you meant to call Essential Killing a ripoff, then just say 'ripoff', e.g. "Seraphim Falls is a shameless ripoff of The Shooting."

Oh whisky, leave me alone.

reply

Sorry for bad wording. What I meant was that Essential Killing is indeed a ripoff. The shooting (1966), don't think I ever saw that one. Maybe it was time for a remake.

So now this move is even less original. The "plot" stolen from The Shooting and the photo and sentiment from Seraphim Falls.

reply

Except the plot isn't stolen from The Shooting, in fact I never even directly compared the two films. Something tells me you missed my point.

Oh whisky, leave me alone.

reply

You are too stupid to flame. Give it a rest.

reply

I actually thought of that one too! And there is a newer one with Mads Mikkelsen called Arctic https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6820256/

reply