MovieChat Forums > Restrepo (2010) Discussion > withdrawal of Korengal

withdrawal of Korengal


This movie shows you
how stupidly we are fighting the war..

Why did we ever withdrawal? That just leaves the Afghani people more reason to NOT trust the Americans.

We said we would protect them, instead we withdrew from many occupied places in Afghanistan.
I believe we are fighting the war very stupidly, we should be more ruthless rather than 'nice' to these people.


=God Bless Our Troops=

reply

Yes, why did we withdraw? That's an excellent question. Does it mean that all that fighting and death and hardship was for nothing?

reply

Fighting for isolated mountain valleys like this one, even if they are hide-outs for clusters of Taliban, was no longer sustainable. It did more to spawn insurgents than defeat them. Better to put those soldiers in cities and towns where they could protect people and help them connect to the Afghan government, [General McChrystal] reasoned.

“There’s never a perfect answer,” General McChrystal said as he visited this outpost on April 8 for a briefing as the withdrawal began. “I care deeply about everybody who has been hurt here, but I can’t do anything about it. I can do something about people who might be hurt in the future.
“The battle changes, the war changes,” he added. “If you don’t understand the dynamics you have no chance of getting it right. We’ve been slower here than I would have liked.”

Forty-two American service men died fighting in the Korangal [sic] and hundreds were wounded, according to military statistics. Most died in the three years from 2006 to 2009. Many Afghan soldiers died there as well and in larger numbers since they had poorer equipment. In a war characterized by small, brutal battles, the Korangal had more than its share, and its abandonment now has left soldiers who fought there confronting confusion, anger and pain.

The Korangal Outpost was the third area of eastern Afghanistan where combat outposts closed: In 2007 and 2008 two posts and a smaller satellite base were closed in Kunar’s Waygal Valley, and in 2009 two posts were closed in Nuristan Province’s Kamdesh region. Along with the main Korangal outpost, five small satellite bases have closed, at least two of them, Restrepo and Vimoto, were named for soldiers who died there.

http://smallwarsjournal.com/blog/2010/04/learning-from-the-korengal-va l/

America is all about speed. Hot, nasty, badass speed. -Eleanor Roosevelt, 1936

reply

Thank you for posting this, DrChrisCooper.

~ Louisville resident. My "Seen" movies: http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=1049228

reply

A better question is why we were ever there in the first place.

"I've seen things that would make you want to write a book on how to puke."

reply