MovieChat Forums > 12th & Delaware Discussion > Doesn't it seem like people on both side...

Doesn't it seem like people on both sides of the isssue


have an ulterior motive beyond simply caring for babies/fetuses/women's rights?

like they want to please god, or go against god, or hate on people.

I just don't think anyone REALLY gives a damn.

If you care, adopt, work in adoption, donate money to those services.

Protesting with grotesque signs is just lame.

reply

I think that the anti-abortion people do give a damn... about the unborn baby. But they don't care very much about the women who are pregnant.

On the one hand I can kind of understand that point of view (although I don't agree with it).

But it's pretty twisted that they think it's OK to make up "facts" and manipulate these women who are so vulnerable to get their way.

reply

Maybe I didn't say it clearly, I just feel that there is some kind of deeper, hidden psychology that runs way more complicated than simply caring about unborn. These people seemed like they were trying to satisfy some internal kind of psychological thirst than save babies.

I'm trying not to sound like i come down on either side of this issue, because I really honestly don't have much of an opinion on it. I'm just fairly convinced the most vocal on the issue have other reasons for being so loud.

reply

I love the way you put that! "These people seemed like they were trying to satisfy some internal kind of psychological thirst than save babies." I think that is the explanation for their state of mind. It's so simple, yet profound.

I don't need no *beep* signature!

reply

I kinda think so too. And I agree with your last sentence.

reply

Did you really mean to write 'people on both sides of the issue'? I ask because you are only giving the "hidden" agenda of the people opposed to abortions. Can you think of any psychological motives for those who approve using abortion as birth control?

reply

Yeah, rebellion against patriarchal moral codes. Like someone pissed off for being raised Catholic, etc.

reply

I can only speak for myself. My name is bonnie until his assaination I worked for Dr. Tiller at his clinic. Before that I have voluntered at clinics in California, Washinton State and Texas.

I care alot about this and the way it effects women. The one abiding absolute is that a woman must have the last decision over who how and what uses her physical person. If she does not have this right she has no other rights worth having. To force a Woman to use her body to sustain a pregnancy against her will is slavery. To force her to terminate a pregnancy against her will is slavery.

As I stated on another thread I am as old as dirt. I remember the start of this war and it was not then or is it now about babies. It began with the introduction of the "pill". Immediately there was the reaction of we can not allow this becuase then women would be alowed to decide their own fertility and would escape their punishment for having sex (especially for enjoying sex) with out the consequence of pregnancy.

If women control their fertility they are able to plan their families space out their children or even decide not to have children at all. They are able to work outside of homes. They can choose to postpone pregnancy until they complete their education. And most of all women who can control their fertility are not dependent on staying with a man becuase they have too many children and not enough training to support themselves.

This battle is over who will define what a woman is and what she can strive for. If it was about babies all these folk who oppose abortion would be working to give women in this society the means to provide for post born babies ( affordable decent day care, good free prenatal care, affordable education for women with children that enables them to compete in the job market for jobs that actually bring in enough to feed and house the babies they have).

Other reasons to deepoly care about this issue are that forced pregnancy and forced abortion are two side of the same coin. If we give the government the power to decide a woman must carry a pregnancy to term then we also have given the government the power to decide she must abort. This country and our government has a history of forcing both sterilization and abortion on group it deemed unfit to reproduce.

I think I am about as "prochoice" as is possible. At my core I believe this is an intimate personal decision that must be left up to the woman with the help of her family and her doctor(s) who have the information about her situation and the risks that she faces. It is her decision becuase she is the one who whatever choice she makes who lives with the consequences of that decision.

I have three daughters and six granddaughters, I care about this issue becuase I don't ever want them forced by anyone else (especially for anothers religious convictions) to eeither abort or carry to term against their will.

Back in the 70's I was beaten (broken jaw, ribs lots of stiches) and rapped by a man (using that term is a joke) who had sworn to love and protect me. two months latter I realized I was pregnant. I cannot begin to tell you how horrified I was that he had forced himself inside me and now part of him was feeding off of me. I decided to kill myself and becuase I had two very small children already and did not want to abandon them to the control of this monster I was going to take them with me. I should also say that at the time AI was living in another country with no money or even my passport (he had that). I thought I had no other option and I knew that I would not carry to term under any circumstances. Then I had an Angel of mercy in the form of my landlady. She knew something was wrong, she had seen the results of the beating. I told her my rape had made me pregnant. this kind lady in her widow weeds and head scarf told me she would help me. She gave me ergott and sat with me while I misscarried. She ran such a high risk to help me (prison) and yet she did. (eventually I did get home with my two kids and away from the creep) I had another daughter a couple of years latter by my second husband. My two older kids had a relatively normal childhood. I owe that woman so much. The only way I can repay her is to be their for other women and tomake sure they have a choice. My abortion was illegal and I had no medical care. I had complications and was unable to go to a clinic or hospital for help. I never want another woman to go through that (especially not my daughters and granddaughters).

I will also say something about the folk I worked with at the clinic. Our motto was "TRUST WOMEN" this was not just a slogn or catch phrase. My boss, Dr. Tiller really beleaved in women and their ability to make the best decisions for them selves and their families. Our satff lived and breathed this concept. My boss not only believed in women but he felt so strongly that they must have a safe legal access to this decision he knowingly put his life on the line. The clinic had been bombed and he had been shot in another assasination attempt. He knew the risks. Several times he told me he "hopped it would be a good clean headshot) He was targeted and murdered in cold blood becuase he refused to give in to thugs and abandon his patients. He was a good family man, a devout Lutheren, and a champion for womens equality. His support of women was not limited to abortion rights. He paid for women to go back to school and get their degrees, he worked with alcohol and drug rehab giving many a second chance. If he knew of someone in need he never hesitated to help. I have watched him many times as he sat up all night with a patient in labor next to her bed with her family. I have also seen him stand up for patients that were being coherced into an abortion by family or others giving them the resources to choose to keep the pregnancy.

The rest of the staff endured protests in front of their houses, anonymous letters mailed to their neighbors, being followed as they shopped or took their kids to day care. We were there when our boss was murdered (not one staff member was ready to quit). Our emplyees had been there through thick and thin with very little turn over. You do not work under these conditions becuase you are peeved at religion (besides most of the staff were practicing christians, especially two of our chaplains) Nor do you stay becuase of some political view. Tey stayed becuase of the patients. We after all spent time with them, knew their stories, their histories. We knew them as real people with real thoughts and needs.

I think it is the same in most clinics.


My sincerest hope would be that no woman would ever have to be in a posistion that abortion is one of her options. Until we have failproof birthcontrol, eliminate rape, and do away with fetal abnomalies and maternal complications, provide the economic means and education to raise women out of poverty there will be a need. Everyone should care especially women becuase no one knows what circumstance they may end up in or someone they care about. In the mean time we should all be focused on making abortion safe legal and very, very rare.















reply

Bonnie, I read your post. I understand where you are coming from and I still firmly disagree with your stance. Let me quote you:

"I cannot begin to tell you how horrified I was that he had forced himself inside me and now part of him was feeding off of me."

I find it scary and common to have the mindset you do. You are a victim of rape. The man that did this sounds like he has very serious issues. The seed which found your egg and began developing was not you or that man. The right for you, me, and everyone else to live is from our creator. We are born into this world which is full of sin (as you said...rapists, murderers, etc). When we are baptized, our decisions become our own. We no longer take responsibilty for the evil done by past men and women and no longer can blame our future sins on the past. This of course absolves the aborted baby due to he or she never being baptized, thus being part of past evil decisions, but it does not absolve you for the decision you made. You and any other mother who has an abortion live with the pain. That baby was the retribution to your rapist. Now the rapist and you for that matter, only have thoughts and memories to haunt you...nothing concrete and physical to defend the truth. All is not lost. Your life continues to make correct choices. God understands all sin...something no man or woman can (which causes us pain). Only believing in God will put you towards the right step.

reply

One don't assume everyone believe like you. You version of a creator is simply your version. I certianly would not make decisions based on anothers narrow perception of the universe.

two the pregnancy was a continuation of the rape. the embryo that resulted from the rape most certianly part of the rapist that he had jamed into my body agaist my will. Until you have been there you just simply put have no concept.

As to living in pain and regret from the abortion. No, no regrets about the abortion. No regrets about having the means to free me to save the two actual children I had or the means to escape my rapist husband. My memories are of a kind old lady who put her own welfare and life on the line to help me. They are filled with love and gratitude.

If I did have any regrets it was that I married a man when I was too young that I thought I had to stay married and that he thought he had the right to beat and rape what he thought was "godgiven" property.

I have to ask on one completely ridiculus statement in your post "That baby was the retribution to your rapist"?

My rapist beat me that last beating becuase I said I was going to leave. The last time I had tried to leave I became pregnant and stayed becuase of the pregnancy. Things only went from bad to worse. There are men who use prenancy as a means to control and hold on to women that might escape their control. My pregnancy and the resulting baby was simply that. Do you think he raped me becuase he was just filled with passion?

You keep your view of the universe thank you I have my own. In mine anyone who would force a woman to carry the product of a rape to term is participating in that rape by proxy.

My vision of the universe(s) has no room for somthing so cruel and unjust.

Now some suvivors of rape that were pregnant choose to keep those pregnancies and I support their choice absolutly. I have a very close friend who did just that. Now twenty years latter she says she has regrets. women are not cookiecutter caritures with uteruses. They are complex creatures with complex lives and mind sets.

reply

[deleted]

yOU ASKED, i'LL ANSWER...simply...2 wrongs do not make a right...I never said the rapist was right...I never said God looked at that behavior as right...I said the rape and the abortion have nothing to do with each other

Please explain how my post proves of inbreeding...or are you just a judgemental bastard.

reply

[deleted]

Our same creator allows independent thought...we are allowed to touch fire and burn ourselves as many times as we want or we can learn from our mistakes and build from them. Our creator that made us is the same that made trees, water, fungus...everything. If you think a human being can do these things, then prove that. Humans made the decisions to protect ourselves from the elements. Not necessary, but certainly a good plan. All God did was produce life and accept it back. It's up to us to make decisions on how long we can survive, thus outlawing murder. It's up to us how long we live in happiness, thus outlawing rape, theft, and many other crimes that are hypocritical and morally wrong. I believe that abortion falls under these unlawful conditions. As far as being a Hellbound prick...well...if so...I tried my best ;)

reply

[deleted]

YOU *beep* PRO-LIFE FASCIST, HOW DARE YOU USE YOUR BRONZE-AGE FAIRLY TALE MYTHS TO SAY THAT PREGNANCY BY RAPE IS RETRIBUTION!

YOU SAID THAT GOD IS AGAINST ABORTION?
READ YOUR *beep* BIBLE, NIV'S NUMBERS 5 11-31, BITCH!

IT'S OWN FOOTNOTE SAID "TO CAUSE A MISCARRYING WOMB AND BARRENNESS."
IN THE REAL WORLD, TO CAUSE A WOMB TO MISCARRY IS ABORTION, AND IN YOUR BIBLE YOUR GOD DIDN'T STOP IT AND IT WAS DONE BY A PREACHER.

SO STOP SPEAKING FOR YOUR MAKE-BELIEVE GOD BECAUSE HE DIDN'T GIVE A *beep* ABOUT ABORTION.




america is becoming a police state.
check out my Biography

reply

First off, seems as if you read your Bible, not mine. I never quoted scripture. I appreciate your assumption that my God is the one written in the Bible though

reply

Re; what is ergot copied from google




Since the Middle Ages, controlled doses of ergot were used to induce abortions and to stop maternal bleeding after childbirth.[11] Ergot extract has been used in pharmaceutical preparations, including Ergot alkaloids in products such as Cafergot (containing caffeine and ergotamine[11] or ergoline) to treat migraine headaches, and ergometrine, used to induce uterine contractions and to control bleeding after childbirth.

reply

your post started off intelligently, then it hit the massive fail.

reply

Bonnie, thanks for telling your story. While I have never been in a position to have to make the choice you did. I will defend your right to make it. I am a God fearing mother of two. My children were conceived in love and will grow up in a stable family with two parents. For anyone to condemn you for the choice you made, has never been in that situation.

I was encouraged that you also spoke of the other side, helping women who have decided to keep their children. The point that is often made that if you are pro-choice you are in turn pro-abortion. I do not know of a single person that thinks this is the best solution. Abortions are not a solution, the solution would be to not have the contributing factors. But, to say any woman should have to carry a child that was the result of such a violent act to just inhumane and frankly cruel.

In biblical times babies that were unable to thrive (due to cleft palettes or other birth defects) were left to die. This was not considered murder, it was the only choice the family had.

Again, I have never had an abortion, so I can not understand the painful decision it would be to terminate your pregnancy. But, because there are monsters out there, who are the real criminals in this matter. I will support a woman's right to choose.

To quote my pro-life (as if the rest of us are not) neighbor, "If I had to chose between my life and the life of my unborn child, I would chose the baby. I know that my son would have to live with his molesting father."

reply

Kmsjs

thank you for your kind words. I think all of us are "pro-life". I simply am more pro womens lives and welfare than I am pro fetal life.

The woman that is sustaining the pregnancy by her own physical body is the one to decide.

Pregnancy, labor and delivery, abortion and motherhood (and you are not made a mother simply by conception excep on the basest terms) all fall on women. We must all work to ensure that these things are done in the best safest ways possible and that all women have access to the education that allows them to make choices that best fit their lives.

reply

[deleted]

Bonnie, I just wanted to tell you I read your entire post and it was a very moving, eloquent, and on-the-point defense of the pro-choice stance. Thank you for sharing your story.

reply

Thank-you for your kind remarks. there are far to many womwn with the same stories.

I want to thank all of the posters on this thread for letting me vent. As long as we are still able to speak out there is hope.

reply

Bonnie, I've made a point to read all of your posts on this film's board yesterday and today, and I just want to join the others in thanking you for continuing your fight for your fellow woman and to apologize that we live in a world where you need to defend yourself against self-centered posters who think your uterus (and the uteri of others) and any embedded foreign body is any of their damned business.

Thank you,thank you, thank you. You are a hero, both to me and, I'll go out on a limb and assume here, to the many women supported in their decisions.

Whatever the decisions were.

Thank you.

reply

My motto is and will always be

Don't believe in abortion...?

Don't have one.

What other people do is between them and no one else should judge what decision is best for them.

reply