MovieChat Forums > Turtles Forever (2009) Discussion > Man... the way the '80s Shredder and Kra...

Man... the way the '80s Shredder and Krang were treated....


Just completely unfair. I would have liked to have seen '80s Shredder and new Shredder team up the way the turtles did, but they were treated like complete idiots. Hell, Bebop and Rocksteady were treated with more respect.

The '80s turtles weren't treated as badly as I was expecting, but '80s Shredder was just a victim, plain and simple.

reply

I always find it funny how internet cultured message board communities get such in a huff about their personal affection towards their childhood items. If only the message board community on the internet could be this passionate about stuff in real life we'd probably have a lot of problems in this world fixed already.

Anyways enough side bar.

I think a lot of people are taking the 'butthurt' attitude towards this movie and not looking at it for what it is. The simple truth is, the 80s cartoon was a simple cash in of the turtles comics, anyone who knows TMNT history can tell you that, but what they also know, but may not admit is, without the 80's cartoon the TMNT franchise as a whole would not be anywhere close to as big as it was.

Americans love a good victim story and love to stand behind one, and someone stealing someone's work (or in this case just cutting someone out of the picture) and cashing in on it, is seen as a huge travesty and something to really get behind and seek revenge (the revenge mentality in this country is borderline fantasy in my opinion), but if that person happens to create something that gets people interested, its simply forgotten until the story of that creation being stolen outshines the creation because the creation is old, outdated or lost its luster. A victim story, especially a cliche such as this, never dies though, just put on hold until its product of the cashin in wanes enough in favoritism.

This cartoon in its purest form was in my opinion gloried fan fiction, and in many ways it was, but it was also a big thank you to the fans.

The fact that the 80s material was thought of so badly was because as a turtles fan you know the truth behind the cartoon, however you still love it because as a child you don't know anything about backroom politics, and as a fan of 80's cartoons in general when you look back at 20+ years later and create something paying homage to it, you take the grand sum of it all and mash it together and what is left is the biggest stereotypes of 80's cartoon culture, which just seems overboard by comparison.

reply

That's really unfair to just pass off genuine complaints as "Butthurt".

Regardless of what the 80's show was in comparison to the source the fact is it was still grossly misrepresented in Turtles Forever and THAT'S what folk are pissed at.

Grated it had it's moments but the 80s show was NEVER that goofy.

If they had accurately portrayed them then ok but they completely exaggerated the daft parts to a permanent feature. The fact that they then relentlessly poked fun at it for basically the whole movie as if that's how it was back then was too much to take.

It's not a case of being butthurt or nostalgic, it's a case of they weren't being fair and changed things to suit themselves for cheap laughs. Besides, if it wasn't for the cartoon The turtles would still be an obscure comic book and that to me deserves some respect.

All the incarnations do.

What we had was a huge middle finger to what basically ignited the franchise as a whole.

reply

but they were bumbling idiots even in the 80s show especially during the later seasons. i rewatched the entire 80s run just couple months ago before i started the 2003 series, and even the voice actors of original shredder and krang said they played the characters like married couple. the 80s show was more of a sitcom than an action cartoon with krang constantly nagging shredder and their harebrained schemes involving digging out the technodrome from wherever it was stuck at the moment, if you rewatch the 80s show now, you'd probably be disgusted by how ridiculous some of the old plots were.

reply

Look at it this way; 80s Shredder is at least smart enough to realize that destroying the source dimension will destroy everything, unlike his rage-blinded counterpart. He's willing to team up with his enemies to stop that from happening and holds his own in the final fight (since when did he know how to use his cape to glide?).

I loved the 80s series, but no one can deny how funny and silly it was. In terms of brutality between Shredders, there's no comparison at all. The 'Giggle Ray' indeed sounds like something they would try.

reply

Not really. He was still always trying to kill them. Unless "giggle ray" was code for "laugh to death similar to joker gas" ray

reply