Chinese Lesbians?


Okay, am I the only one that's getting that kind of vibe from the trailer?


http://www.youtube.com/enid1911

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

No, no lesbianism whatsoever, it's not uncommon to see Chinese females hold hands and have a lot of affection for each other. I've seen it in Hong Kong, I've seen it in Mainland China, I've seen men also hold hands on occasion, but very rarely and no, they were not gay. It's just a cultural thing. I've seen Chinese girls do it in the States as well.

-The Price of freedom is eternal vigilance.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I read the book and watched the movie, trust me... they are just friends.

This is probably what the others were talking about:
In the book there is this chapter where they practice Nu Shu on each others back, and also on a few other parts of the body. Lily indeed felt some sort of sensation from it but it was nothing sexual, they didn't touch each others most private body parts.

Just because two girls have a very intimate and loving friendship doesn't mean there are homosexual undertones... In this century people always read between the lines.. Face it, not everyone is gay, and these kind of friendships do exist.

In the movie the girls both have men they loved and had sex with, so please... it's not a lesbian movie.

__________________________________

how'd you like to love me forever

reply

Yes, it's a very different culture and especially with Snow Flower and Lily - it's also a very different period and female friendship had a very great value. At the end of the movie it was nothing more than a very strong connection beyond just simple friendship. It was an emotional, promised bond between two sisters. It's pretty beautiful... I wish I had someone like that

(•_•)

can't outrun your own shadow

reply

No, they are as much as lesbians a Oprah and Gayle! There is no definition for those kind of friendships between two females!

reply

I've been blessed to have had a same-sex friend since we were only 4 years old so I could easily grasp and appreciate that the characters felt a profound love for one another but were in NO WAY lesbians!

It's sad that you have not experienced a truly loving friendship based on EVERYTHING other than sex, Enid1911.

( for you.)

reply

Wtf is so wrong with thinking this movie has a lesbian subtext? It's okay to disagree with it, but acting so damn offended is unnecessary. I, for one, thought there were some romantic undertones between the two, especially in the book. They weren't strapping on the dildos, but their most intimate emotional and mental relationship was with each other. And yes, they did have a very sensual experience with each other at one point.

But God help us if they had some romantic feelings for each other because that makes them dirty vegan finger-lickin' LESBIANS and that makes the book LESBIAN and this movie LESBIAN and therefore should only be viewed by LESBIANS *beep* other LESBIANS. God-LESBIAN-dammit.

reply

There is no real equivalent of a laotong relationship in our culture, but I do believe there was definitely some homoerotic subtext between the two main characters and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. They obviously had a relationship where they were extremely close, but truly in a sister kind of way, like some of the other books written by Lisa See. This author definitely focuses on relationship between women, and women the different kinds of relationships between women. The feelings and relationship between Snow Flower and Lily are an example, they differ from the biological sister relationship in her Shanghai Girls novel, and also from the relationships that the main character of Peony in Love had with other women.

reply