MovieChat Forums > Exodus: Gods and Kings (2014) Discussion > Atheists shouldn't be directing Christia...

Atheists shouldn't be directing Christian films...


One of the main attractions of Christian films that makes it come alive are people who truly believe in what they're doing. Cecil B Demilles Ten Commandments did well be somewhere those actors and actresses had a belief in God or believed in the moralistic tenets of Christianity.

reply

Malayada I typed your name but it came up Malaysia sorry --- damn phone

reply

Well you know, a lot of people didn't know that Abraham Lincoln killed vampires until that movie came out so...

I would say my memory is not what it used to be. But I don't remember what my memory used to be.

reply

You mean Jewish. The Ten Commandments is about the freedom of Hebrews from Ramses. Not tne Christians.

But I agree. This film should have been directed by someone who knows and adore the story of the source material. This film should have never been grounded as it was presented. It took the entire magic and beauty out of this great tale.

reply

Exactly.

reply

You do realize that the story has been translated through many languages, retranslated, adapted, etc. by so many people through the ages that it's impossible to know the exact story by this point? So a director's retelling is just the same as the story itself, a retelling...

reply

Want the exact story? Ask a Rabbi or read our Torah.

reply

So by your logic, christians shouldn't make movies about non-Christian things. No movies containing no Christian themes, every Christian should make only Christian movies and leave all other films to atheists? How absurd
...

reply

You should really chill with the whole calling women sluts thing. It makes you look like a spoiled little child, and it isn't something that should be tolerated.

reply

An atheist can do religious movie if they have respect for it, clearly neither Ridley, Christian or anybody had respect for this story.

Superman & Wonder Woman

reply

Exactly. Religion is really about having a relationship with the divine. If it was a gay or transgendered person or a Christian seeker ( a person who was raised a Christian but has issues with the internal struggles and trying to understand what God has allowed to occur in the world yet they still seek after God and pray but even look into different religions due to their earnestness of trying to find the real creator of heaven and earth. I don't go along with looking into everything but if there is sincerity I believe the real creator will manifest himself to that person. It's a heart relationship) so if a sincere person writes a Jewish or Christian film and sincerity is there you'll pick it up from the film. I picked up no reverence or respect for the creator from this film.

reply

In other words if the person is gay or transgendered or atheist and has a sincere heart to want to know the divine you'd pick it up. And I'm not talking about religion but an actual spiritual experience.

reply

Yeah, that's why Christians never rewrite anything. After all, there's only one version of the Bible.

-Nam

I am on the road less traveled...

reply

Try harder. Christianity was long after this fable was supposed to occur.

reply

What are you talking about? What does that have to do with the plethora of versions of the Bible that Christians find new ways to rewrite, water down, omit, etc.,?

You try harder

-Nam

reply